Assessing Issuer Stock Buybacks: Purpose and Preliminary Considerations | Practical Law

Assessing Issuer Stock Buybacks: Purpose and Preliminary Considerations | Practical Law

A collection of resources to assist companies and their counsels in considering and implementing a stock repurchase program.

Assessing Issuer Stock Buybacks: Purpose and Preliminary Considerations

Practical Law Legal Update 1-584-1345 (Approx. 6 pages)

Assessing Issuer Stock Buybacks: Purpose and Preliminary Considerations

by Practical Law Corporate & Securities
Published on 29 Oct 2015USA (National/Federal)
A collection of resources to assist companies and their counsels in considering and implementing a stock repurchase program.
A public company has a strong interest in the market price of its securities. The market price of its common stock serves as an indicator of the health and performance of the company, and may also impact the price of a future acquisition or the amount of capital raised in a future securities offering. One way a company can positively affect the price of its common stock is to repurchase shares of its common stock in the open market.
Mature public companies are continuing to buy back their own stock. There are many legitimate business reasons for a company to initiate a share repurchase program:
  • Increase the market price of its common stock. A company may implement a stock buyback when management believes that the market has discounted its share price. When a company announces a buyback, there is frequently an increase in market activity and an increase in the market price for the shares.
  • Return invested capital. Investors view issuer repurchases as an appropriate method of returning cash to stockholders. A stock buyback is a tax-efficient alternative to declaring a dividend. The cash investors receive for the repurchase of their shares is treated as a capital gain rather than ordinary income subject to a higher tax rate. In addition, a repurchase program allows the company to use its excess cash when more favorable investments are unavailable.
  • Reduce dilution. A company can use stock repurchases to offset the dilutive impact of stock options and restricted stock granted under employee equity incentive compensation plans.
  • Improve per share earnings. On completion of the buyback there will be fewer shares outstanding, which causes an increase in earnings per share.
However, despite the positive impact of buyback programs, companies must be mindful of the growing number of critics claiming that buybacks:
  • Imply that management is not adequately investing in the business, favoring short-term results over long-term growth, or does not know how to properly manage the business.
  • Are being used to artificially increase earnings per share when profits are stagnant.
  • Are being used to fuel executive compensation at the expense of other stakeholders. For example, companies buy back their stock to offset the impact of executive stock option exercises and stock award vesting so that the outstanding share count remains the same and dilution is avoided.
If considering a stock repurchase program, as a preliminary matter, the company and its counsel must review the following to ensure they do not restrict or prohibit the stock repurchase:
  • The company's organizational documents.
  • The company's material contracts, including credit agreements and indentures.
  • Any outstanding orders, judgments or similar rulings that could restrict or prohibit the repurchase.
  • State corporation laws and other laws that could restrict or prohibit the repurchase.
  • Any other regulations applicable to the company, such as industry-specific regulations.
The company must also review and ensure compliance with the following:
  • Rules and requirements of the securities exchange on which its stock is listed.
  • Federal securities laws, rules and regulations.

Featured Stock Repurchase Resources

Practical Law offers several resources to assist companies and their counsel in considering and implementing a stock repurchase program: