Commercial real estate in Mexico: overview
A Q&A guide to corporate real estate law in Mexico.
The Q&A gives a high level overview of the corporate real estate market trends; real estate investment structures, including REITs; legislation; title and public registers of title; confidential information; state guarantee of title; tenure; sale of real estate; seller's liability; due diligence; warranties; cost; taxes and mitigation, including VAT and stamp duty/transfer tax; climate change targets; third party outsourcing; restrictions on foreign ownership or occupation; finance; leases; planning law and consents; and proposals for reform.
To compare answers across multiple jurisdictions, visit the Corporate Real Estate Country Q&A tool.
This Q&A is part of the PLC multi-jurisdictional guide to corporate real estate law. For a full list of jurisdictional Q&As visit www.practicallaw.com/realestate-mjg.
The corporate real estate market
Office space. Mexico City has the largest inventory of modern, quality office space in Latin America. As of the third quarter of 2012, the total Class A office space available is 3.9 million square metres and the vacancy rate is approximately 10.4%.
Since the beginning of 2010 through to the end of 2012, Mexico City developers have delivered approximately 1.1 million square metres of new office space, which is a 37% increase in the total inventory in just three years. Fortunately, net demand for quality office space has almost kept pace. Therefore, despite an unprecedented surge in new construction, the overall market has retained a healthy balance between supply and demand and rental rates have generally remained stable.
Another 400,000 square metres is currently under construction for delivery before the end of 2014. With approximately half of that space already pre-committed, it is anticipated that the market will continue to be stable in the immediate future.
One notable change in conditions is that over the past several years, demand for office space has demonstrated a notable geographic shift away from the popular western suburban markets back to more central locations closer to white collar residential neighborhoods and with better access to public transportation. Therefore the market is experiencing growing vacancy rates and lower prices in the suburbs, with lower vacancy rates and slightly rising rental rates in the central business districts.
Construction financing. For the past 20 years, 95% of Mexico City office space has been constructed by domestic developers, a trend that prevails today. Construction financing has always been difficult to obtain and interest rates on project financing are high, so the vast majority of office space has been built with equity or with important components of equity. However, since the early 1990s, Mexico office buildings with long-term, quality tenants, unique to Latin America, have been able to attract non-recourse, US dollar, fixed-rate, long-term permanent mortgage financing, supplied by an array of foreign institutional lenders. Therefore, many owners have been able to partially re-finance with comparatively low-cost dollar mortgages with lengthy amortisation periods.
Foreign ownership. Foreign institutional ownership of Mexico office buildings has been less popular than for industrial real estate, however there is evidence of growing interest. Today, less than 10% of office ownership is held by foreign institutions but industry experts believe that figure may double over the next five years. Recent changes to Mexican law allowing government-regulated pension funds (called AFORES) to invest in real estate have given rise to the creation of local real estate investment funds set up to access this new money (see Question 2, Common structures).
The most significant deals (that is, deals involving real estate space of more than 10,000 square metres) in the past twelve months have included:
Banco Compartamos: 18,000 square metres in Insurgentes.
ICA Fluor Daniel: 18,000 square metres in Insurgentes.
Colgate-Palmolive: 15,000 square metres in Polanco.
Zurich Seguros: 11,000 square metres in Polanco.
Real estate investment
The structures most commonly used by private investors are:
Stock companies (sociedades anónimas).
Limited liability companies (sociedades de responsabilidad limitada).
A few years ago, the investment promotion stock company (Sociedad Anónima Promotora de Inversión) (SAPI) was introduced, which is a sociedad anónima commonly used among real estate private investors as it is an excellent vehicle to structure joint ventures for the development of projects in all areas of industry and commerce (including real estate projects).
Another structure used to invest in real estate is for a trust to issue certificados de capital de desarrollo (CECADES) under a trust agreement. The CECADES are designed to be acquired by public offer by Mexican pension funds (AFORES) and other institutional investors. The trust issues CECADES which are acquired by investors through the Mexican Stock Exchange (Bolsa Mexicana de Valores). The proceeds are then considered part of the trust estate to invest in promoted companies.
The Mexican equivalent of REITS are Fideicomisos de Infraestructura y Bienes Raíces (FIBRAs), introduced in 2004 through a reform of the Income Tax Law. FIBRAs grant tax benefits to real estate developers who construct or purchase real estate. A FIBRA structure can be implemented through a trust or a Mexican stock company, in the latter case it is called a Sociedad de Inversion en Bienes Raices (SIBRA). Last year (2011), the first FIBRA was launched on the Mexican Stock Exchange and more are expected to launch in the near future.
Institutional investors, like banks or insurance companies, mainly invest through the Mexican Stock Exchange or securities like CECADES, and other public securities.
Foreign investors and private equity funds are investing passively in some real estate projects by associating (through different forms of partnership) with domestic participants, who own substantial portions of undeveloped land, have important expertise in the local market or in developing real estate projects. Instead of voting restrictions, the investment vehicles are subject to negative controls (alienation) and accountability schemes.
Real estate legislation
The main sources of real estate law are the:
Constitution of 1917.
Federal and State Civil Codes.
Foreign Investment Law 1993.
Agrarian Law 1992.
National Estate Assets Law 2004.
General Law of Ecological Equilibrium and Environmental Protection 1988.
General Law for the Prevention and Integral Management of Waste and its Regulations 2003 (Waste Law).
Local Urban Development Laws.
Local Condominium Regime Laws.
Local Construction Regulations.
On 4 April 2012, certain amendments to the Condominium Regime Law for the Federal District (published in 2011) came into effect and on 24 July 2012 several amendments to the Civil Code of the Federal District, mainly in connection with the public registry of property, the regulation of sales in instalments and of sales subject to retention of title, came into effect.
Title to real estate
Title and registers
Real estate comprises land, buildings and other structures attached to it (structures that if removed damage the property or construction).
Traditional civil law elements of land ownership include a right to use (ius utendi), to dispose of (ius abutendi) and to enjoy (ius fruendi) the real estate. Normally, title to land and buildings on it are recorded together, by means of a public deed registered at the corresponding public land registry where the real estate is located. Under Mexican law, ownership of land entitles the owner to everything that the land produces, or that is adjoined to or incorporated into the land, whether naturally or artificially (accession right). However, it is always advisable to confirm that the landowner owns the structures on it. Facilities constructed after a parcel of land is acquired do not form part of the title deed and other means of evidence or elements to help evidence title to the facilities must be used (for example, construction invoices and a construction licence).
Title to land and buildings (subject to subsequent facilities (see Question 4)) is evidenced by a public deed, granted before a notary public and registered at the public registry of property.
Title to land can also be evidenced by:
Agrarian certificates. These are only used for certain transactions involving land that was formerly subject to the ejido regime. The ejido is a population nucleus with its own legal identity and estate the same as that assigned to local inhabitants for farmland purposes by the government. The ejido is the owner of the real estate that has been granted to it, or that it acquired through other means and subsequently incorporated into existing ejido lands.
Each public registry of property is managed by the local government authority.
Information in the public register
There is a public registry of real estate in every state, which records:
Transfers of real estate.
Liens and encumbrances.
Condominium, time-share and fractional ownership regimes.
Other relevant notes on the title of the property.
Generally, the registered owner of the property or a real estate lien holder can make an entry on the registry or on the title.
In most states, registration of a public deed in the registry has a declarative effect (that is, the registration makes the transfer enforceable against third parties). However, between the contracting parties, the transfer is effected by execution of the sale contract. The only exception relates to transfers and encumbrances made in the state of Quintana Roo, where registration has a constitutive effect (that is, the registration of a public deed in the registry is a condition for the transfer of property or of the creation of liens).
Protection from disclosure
There is no way of protecting the information from disclosure. All documents subject to registration in the corresponding public registry (see Question 6) are available to the public. Depending on the state, public registry records can be reviewed through a real estate file number or a certificate of background information recorded for the property. The fees vary, depending on the state. The trend is for public registries to computerise information (although the process has been slow).
State guarantee of title
There is no specific state guarantee of title. A buyer can file a claim for damages and compensation for loss of profit from the state, for an error made by the state in the registry. However, the state is not liable for mistakes made by others (such as the notary public in charge of drawing up the relevant public deed).
In addition, buyers are protected with a statutory indemnity (saneamiento para el caso de evicción) under civil law. If the buyer is evicted from the land because of a judicial decision arising from a claim made by a third party with a superior or better right over the land, then the buyer is entitled to receive damages and compensation for loss of profit from the seller.
Title insurance is available to buyers and lenders, although title insurance agreements are not specifically regulated under Mexican law. However, title insurance companies are regulated under the Insurance Companies Law. Their clients are mostly US companies and their Mexican subsidiaries.
Real estate tenure is based on either:
Rights in rem, including:
fee simple rights over real estate (that is, land held in perpetuity); and
rights which limit ownership of real estate, for example mortgages, easements or usufruct (that is, the right to use and enjoy the benefits of something belonging to another as long as the property is not damaged or altered).
Foreign persons have restrictions on their tenure of rights in rem (see Question 22).
Rights in personam, which are rights derived from a contract that creates personal rights, including:
bailment agreements known as commodatums (that is, the act of delivering goods or personal property in use to another for no specific consideration).
Sale of real estate
Main stages and documents
Marketing of real estate is usually carried out through real estate brokers, acting either as individuals or entities, which charge a percentage of the value of the transaction on completion. On 23 August 2012, the Law on the Rendering of Real Estate Services of the Federal District (Ley de Prestación de Servicios Inmobiliarios) was published in the local Offcial Gazzete (and came into effect one day after). This law is intended to regulate the real estate sector and give more certainty to purchasers of real estate who contract with real estate brokers. Under the Law, from 23 August 2013 all real estate brokers must be registered with a new registry called the Real Estate Professionals Registry (Registro de Profesionales Inmobiliarios) and must be authorised by the Ministry of Economic Development of the Federal District.
In many cases real estate brokers or the sellers directly conduct initial negotiations. It is advisable to involve legal counsel from the early stages of the transaction, to provide legal advice on aspects such as:
Review and investigation of title.
The activities that will be carried out at the property by the new owner (such as a regulated industry or business).
Due diligence on certain material aspects in addition to title (for example, urban development, construction and condominium regimes).
Negotiation of the final purchase agreement.
Possible environmental concerns.
Legal counsel may also be involved at this stage if the buyer requires a binding obligation from the seller, for example, a promise of sale contract (see below, When legally binding).
A typical real estate transaction involves the following stages and documents, including pre-contractual arrangements:
A letter of intent.
A promise of sale contract, or a sale contract subject to conditions precedent (such as Federal Competition Commission (FCC) clearance for certain major transactions).
Loan documentation, such as a term sheet and a loan agreement.
A mortgage or guarantee to secure payment of any outstanding obligations under the loan agreement.
Depending on the structure of the transaction, the sale contract can be executed in different ways, for example, with a reserve of ownership (Reserva de Dominio) (title is not transferred until the purchase price is paid in full or in instalments, or where the property is immediately transferred but the contract can be rescinded if default in payment occurs). The sale contract can be either:
Ad corpus, that is, based on the boundaries and total area of the property. Therefore, if the verifiable boundaries of the property do not match the total identified area, as they may exceed or be less than the area identified, the price cannot be changed.
Ad mesuram, that is, the price is based on the actual area located within the boundaries (price per square metre).
When legally binding
Except for in the State of Quintana Roo, both promises of sale contracts and sale contracts are binding on execution. The laws of Quintana Roo specifically require a sale contract to be registered at the public registry before becoming a valid and enforceable document.
The Consumers Protection Bureau (CPB) has issued certain forms of agreements for major housing and commercial developments that developers must follow. These forms contain certain obligations concerning formalities and disclosure information to protect consumers.
On completion, the real estate transfer document must be registered in the corresponding public registry of property.
When title transfers
While promise of sale contracts that are subject to conditions precedent are binding, title generally passes when the parties execute the transfer agreement (final agreement), unless subject to a condition precedent or to retention of title (see above, Sale contract). Real estate transactions whereby title is transferred must be completed before a notary public.
The final agreement is the same document as the sale contract, but in the form of a public deed and is granted before a notary public. This may require authorisation from the FCC if certain monetary thresholds are met. Even if none of the thresholds are met, the FCC can investigate and challenge the transfer agreement if it deems that it is anti-competitive. The FCC can start an investigation up to one year from completion of the transaction (that is, when the public deed has been registered in the public registry of property).
Seller's liability to the buyer
Real estate due diligence is always recommended when purchasing real estate. The extent of the due diligence depends on the characteristics of the transaction (for example, rural or urban property and agreed price). Although there is no specific rule, buyers generally require between 30 and 90 days to perform due diligence, involving title investigation (including investigating any agricultural background) as well as zoning and environmental studies.
Warranties usually given by a seller include:
Legitimate ownership and title over the real estate.
No liens, ownership reserves, limitation or claims affecting the real estate.
No arrears of tax in relation to the real estate.
No environmental liabilities.
No agrarian background (if this were the case).
In the past, the remediation of soil contamination was solely the responsibility of the responsible party that generated hazardous waste and polluted soil with it. However, since 6 January 2004, the Waste Law and its subsequently enacted regulations provide that owners and/or possessors of real estate with contaminated soil are jointly and severally liable for its clean up. This is irrespective of any claim owners and/or occupiers may have against the polluter.
The Waste Law does not expressly require a seller to determine whether the site is contaminated or not. Therefore, depending on the transaction, a buyer may have to undertake a comprehensive environmental audit of the site's environmental condition before completing the transaction, because if soil contamination exists at the site the buyer is liable for clean-up after the acquisition.
Again, depending on the characteristics of the sale, it is highly advisable for the buyer to, among other things:
Conduct a search of contaminated sites that are registered with the public registry of property. Once a site is deemed contaminated, the relevant authority can record this in the public registry of property, although there are still many states that are unwilling to make such registrations. These searches have been introduced by the Waste Law and its regulations, but are not yet fully implemented.
Conduct a legal environmental due diligence process, which includes a review of, among other documents, all environmental permits, licences, concession titles and authorisations.
Depending on the type of property, conduct an environmental site assessment (either Phase I or Phase II surface investigation studies).
Negotiate a sale or lease agreement that contains comprehensive environmental representations, warranties and indemnities, including an obligation on the seller or landlord to clean up soil contamination found after the acquisition. Any claims relating to the breach of representations and warranties are only enforceable against the seller of a contaminated site.
For leased premises, unless otherwise agreed, an assignee of a lease must remedy defaults of the previous tenant (for example, for repair of the property). The transfer of a lease implies the assignment of the rights and obligations of the previous tenant.
Under applicable Mexican environmental laws and regulations, owners and possessors of sites whose soils are affected by contamination are jointly and severally liable for their remediation, regardless of any actions the owners and possessors may have against the contaminating party and aside from any liability the contaminating party may have. The environmental liability arises for the buyer of a contaminated real property if and when the buyer takes title to or possession of the land, and cannot prove to the Ministry of the Environment and Natural Resources (Secretaría de Medio Ambiente y Recursos Naturales) (SEMARNAT) (see box, Real estate organisations) that the seller assumed liability for pre-existing contamination on transfer.
Although the buyer and seller can contractually agree indemnification in relation to contamination existing before the transaction, governmental agencies are entitled to bring actions against the buyer for remediation of the site (regardless of the actions they may also bring against the party that contaminated the site (for example, the seller or previous tenant)).
Retention of liability after disposal
A seller is liable (that is, it must indemnify and compensate the buyer) for:
Eviction of the buyer, if a third party has superior title.
Hidden defects in the property for up to six months from the transfer. However, the parties can agree otherwise under the relevant state Civil Code.
The Waste Law and its regulations prohibit the transfer of any site contaminated with hazardous waste without the prior authorisation of SEMARNAT. If no responsible party is determined at the time of the transfer, the seller is deemed responsible for contamination. In addition to obtaining authorisation, the seller of a contaminated site must inform the buyer of any contamination or the presence of any hazardous materials.
Under Mexican law a person or entity may attract environmental liability if its actions or omissions either:
Breach Mexican environmental laws, regulations or standards.
Generate contamination or damage to the environment, natural resources or human health.
The party causing soil contamination is ultimately responsible for carrying out or paying for remedial actions to clean up contaminated sites (polluter pays principle) (General Law on Ecological Equilibrium and Environmental Protection and General Law on the Prevention and Comprehensive Management of Waste and its Regulations). Therefore, a seller of land that may have contaminated the land may remain liable for carrying out remedial works, to the extent it is proved to the government that the seller caused the contamination, irrespective of any contractual arrangements.
Seller and buyer costs
Costs involved in the acquisition of real estate usually include:
Notary public fees.
Government registration fees.
Real estate transfer taxes.
Value added tax, in case of constructions.
In practice, the buyer pays all of the costs listed above, although many state Civil Codes allow a 50:50 split between the buyer and seller. Real estate transfer taxes are always payable by the buyer (see Question 18).
See above, Buyer's costs. The seller is responsible for the payment of IETU (see Question 17) and income tax.
Non-Mexican residents are subject to a 25% income tax on the purchase price, or alternatively to a 30% income tax on the gain. Gain is determined between the sale price and the tax basis (that is, the acquisition price plus adjustment over inflation basis, less amortisation of constructions). No flat tax is payable by seller when it is a Non-Mexican resident.
When the seller is a Mexican resident (legal entity) the gain is subject to the 30% income tax rate or a 17.5% flat tax, whichever is higher. Flat tax basis is determined in the same way as income tax, except where the real estate was acquired before 2008, in which case there is no tax basis and the 17.5% applies to the sale price.
Real estate taxes and mitigation
The seller or landlord must charge VAT to the buyer or tenant and deliver the VAT to the relevant tax authority.
In most cases, VAT is charged at the rate of 16%. The following exceptions apply:
Tenants who lease property in border areas are charged VAT at 11%.
Purchases and leases of residential premises and all purchases of land are exempt from VAT.
As a result of the flat tax (Impuesto Empresarial a Tasa Única) (IETU), implemented in Mexico in 2008, the seller or landlord of real estate must pay a flat tax on income received from the sale, purchase, or lease of real estate at the rate of 17.5%. Taxpayers can offset payment of federal income tax against the flat tax.
Real estate transfer tax is imposed on any acquisition of real estate in Mexico. For these purposes, the acquisition of real estate is any act that transfers ownership, including:
This tax is generally 2% of the value of the property.
Following the Fiscal Law of the Federal District (Mexico City), real estate transfer tax is triggered on execution of an agreement for:
The sale of property in Mexico City where the title is retained until payment is fully made (Reserva de Dominio).
The transfer of property in Mexico City, either as a sale or donation.
Real estate transfer tax is generally charged on the highest of the:
Value used for property tax purposes (cadastral).
Value determined by an independent valuation carried out by an authorised appraiser.
In some states, certain incentive programmes allow buyers or developers of land to obtain reductions of up to 100% of real estate transfer tax or property taxes.
Before the execution of a sale contract, a notary public must obtain certificates of no liens and no indebtedness of property tax or other local contributions. If at the request of the parties these certificates are not obtained, completion can still take place, but the notary public is relieved from all tax liabilities. The public registry of property will not record any transfer of property if it becomes aware that all local property taxes and contributions have not been fully paid.
Holding business premises
Climate change targets
There are currently no targets to reduce greenhouse gas emissions from buildings in Mexico.
On 14 January 2010, the Protocol of Activities for Implementing Energy Efficient Actions in Real Estate Properties, Premises and Vehicle Fleets of the Federal Public Administration (Protocolo de Actividades para la Implementación de Acciones de Eficiencia Energética en Inmuebles, Flotas Vehiculares e Instalaciones de la Administración Pública Federal) (Protocol) was published in the Official Gazette of the Federation. The Protocol aims to set out a continuous improvement process for promoting energy efficiency in assets of the federal public administration, through the implementation of good practices and technological innovation. The Protocol obliges federal public administration entities to deliver, for approval, their programmes with their respective energy saving objectives.
In the short term, the objective is mainly the implementation of good practices, while mid- and long-term objectives include investment in high efficiency and innovative technologies. The Protocol applies to real estate properties owned or leased by entities of the federal public administration with a surface area of over 1,000 square metres, for office or any other use.
In addition, certain Official Mexican Norms currently in force set out the guidelines for energy efficiency of different kinds of equipment or machinery that may be used in buildings, for example, certain types of air conditioners or lighting systems.
Third party outsourcing
Outsourcing transactions are typically carried out for efficiency purposes and professional reasons. As real estate developments continue to grow and become more sophisticated, demand for more specialised outsourcing services by independent third parties has also increased. Congress is currently discussing a new Labour Law Bill intending, among other matters, to regulate outsourcing activities in general.
Restrictions on foreign ownership or occupation
Subject to obtaining a permit from the Ministry of Foreign Affairs (see box, Real estate organisations), foreign nationals can own any real estate located outside the restricted zone. The restricted zone is a strip of 100 kilometres along national borders and 50 kilometres along the coast. Foreign persons who want to acquire rights in connection with property in the restricted zone can either:
Lease the property.
Acquire a beneficial interest through a trust agreement. A Mexican bank is the trustee of the property and the foreign person holds the right to use and enjoy the property. The foreign person can instruct the Mexican bank to encumber or transfer title to a person identified by the foreign person and receive the proceeds of the sale of the property.
Mexican companies that are wholly-owned by foreign persons can acquire non-residential properties located within the restricted zone.
Issues on change of control
Change of control does not usually affect a company's holding of real estate, unless a foreign investor (that is, either a foreign individual or company, or a Mexican company controlled by foreign nationals) acquires control or a participation in a Mexican company, in which case certain restrictions apply (see Question 22).
The states' Civil Codes do not contain limitations on change of control provisions in leases, although the parties can freely agree limitations.
Federal or state authorities can only compulsorily purchase business premises through expropriation for public policy reasons, for example, when land is required for the construction of highways or energy plants. The government must always indemnify the owners at market value determined by an appraisal valuation entity.
A compulsory sale can occur to cover the tax debt resulting from tax evasion. The relevant authorities must follow the applicable legal procedure, which concludes with a bidding and an auction sale.
There are no specific municipal, state or federal taxes payable on the occupation of business premises. However, under certain local state tax laws, the landlord of leased properties must pay local real estate property tax on a higher tax basis than for other properties, because leased real estate properties produce a regular income. This tax accrues every two months, but can be paid annually, for which the local authorities usually grant a special discount.
Certain government fees (derechos) are payable to the municipality when it issues an operating licence or permit to conduct business. The fees are determined annually and are published in the relevant Revenue Law.
There are currently no incentives or exemptions.
Real estate finance
Finance is commonly raised by granting real estate as collateral through a security trust agreement (fideicomiso de garantía) and/or a mortgage (hipoteca).
Under a security trust agreement, the settlor (borrower or guarantor) (fideicomitente) transfers title to real property in favour of a trustee (typically a Mexican banking institution), to secure payment of secured obligations in favour of the lender as beneficiary. The settlor, however, retains a secondary beneficial interest in the collateral so that on satisfaction of the secured obligations, legal title to the collateral reverts back to it.
The security trust agreement has certain unique advantages, such as the ability to agree and provide for an extra-judicial foreclosure procedure and certain insolvency benefits. Legal title to the collateral is transferred to the trustee as trust property (propiedad fiduciaria). Therefore, as a general rule, in the event of insolvency of the settlor (assuming it is a Mexican entity), the collateral held by the trustee under the security trust agreement should not be consolidated with the assets of the settlor.
Since 2004, the securitisation of mortgage portfolios has been a valuable source of financing, particularly for the housing sector and the real estate market in general. This method consists of attracting resources from the public through the issue of stock exchange certificates by a trust, supported by a mortgage loan portfolio originated by one or more financial institutions.
Sale and leaseback transactions are also commonly used.
The most common forms of security granted over real estate to raise finance are the security trust agreement (fideicomiso de garantía) and the mortgage (hipoteca) (see Question 27). Both securities are:
Created by execution in public deed form before a notary public. For a security trust, the deed must be executed by the settlor, trustee and beneficiary.
Perfected by registration with the public registry of property of the jurisdiction where the real estate is located.
The first public mortgage-backed securitisation took place in 2003. Although the first mortgage-backed securitisation transactions were structured as simple securitisations of discreet pools of mortgage loans, the Mexican securitisation market began to become more sophisticated and mortgage securitisation structures became more complex. Early mortgage-backed securitisations typically included a mortgage guarantee from Mexico's mortgage development bank, the Sociedad Hipotecaria Federal (SHF). Reforms to Mexican insurance laws and regulations in 2004 allowed Mexican private insurance companies to grant financial guarantees and mortgage insurance in relation to mortgage-backed securitisation structures which soon replaced SHF's guarantee. In addition, the active role of multilateral institutions such as the Inter-American Development Bank and the Overseas Private Investment Corporation in the Mexican mortgage-backed securities market speeded up the development of mortgage-backed securitisations.
Until the financial crisis of 2008, mortgage-backed securitisations continued to flourish and to become more sophisticated. In addition, although the securitisation of mortgage loans gave way to the securitisation of other asset classes, mortgage-backed securities continued to dominate the Mexican structured products market. Although the 2008 crisis brought about a sudden halt in the continued development of the Mexican mortgage-backed securities market, the revival of the Mexican economy continues.
In 2010 and 2011, the Mexican capital markets saw several significant transactions, some of which were asset securitisation transactions.
Real estate leases
Negotiation and execution of leases
Depending on the location of the real estate, the relevant Civil Codes can apply to commercial leases. The Civil Codes set out the basic general rights and obligations of the parties, most of which apply unless the parties agree otherwise. Rent is not regulated, but must meet certain criteria of rent set out in the Civil Codes. For example, under the Civil Code for the Federal District, the rent in leases for residential use must be agreed upon in Mexican pesos and can only be increased annually. Also, most Civil Codes establish a maximum term for leases depending on the use to be given to the premises (for example, residential, commercial and industrial).
Often, landlords require a guarantee that the tenant will comply with the lease, including timely payment of rent. The tenant provides this by delivering a surety bond issued by a third party (such as a parent company), or by an authorised institution that issues bonds. Some landlords require corporate guarantees from parent companies.
Unforeseen circumstances that affect the equity of contracted obligations enable a modification in the contractual terms and conditions in favour of the negatively affected party, subject to the agreement of the parties or the decision of the competent judicial authority (Law on Public Sector's Acquisitions, Leases and Services (Ley de Adquisiciones, Arrendamientos y Servicios del Sector Público)).
Generally, there are no formal legal requirements to execute a lease, except that leases must be in writing. However certain states such as Durango, require that the lease is formalised as a public deed before a notary public when the rent exceeds a certain nominal amount. In most states, leases executed for more than six years must be executed or ratified before a notary public and registered in the corresponding public registry of property.
Rent levels and reviews
Due to inflation, leases usually contain escalation provisions under which rent can be adjusted annually according to the Consumers Price Index, published by the Mexican Central Bank (downward rent adjustments are uncommon).
The landlord must charge the tenant VAT at 16% of the rent, except for leased properties in border areas where VAT is 11%. The landlord is responsible to the tax authorities for delivering the tax (see Question 17).
Similarly, the landlord must directly pay IETU (flat tax) at 17.5% on the income received from rent (see Question 17).
Length of term and security of occupation
Certain statutory limits apply to the length of the lease depending on:
The state in which the real estate is located.
The type of leased property (for example, commercial leases generally range from ten to 20 years and industrial leases from 15 to 20 years).
Unless otherwise agreed, the tenant has no right to renew the lease without the landlord's consent. In most states, if a tenant continues to use a property after the lease term has expired, without opposition from the landlord, the lease is extended indefinitely, depending on if the property is rural or urban. Either party can terminate the lease in these circumstances, subject to the terms of the lease.
Restrictions on disposal
Use of premises within a corporate group
Tenants can only share their business premises with the landlord's permission, through a sub-lease or bailment agreement (see Question 9).
Repair and insurance responsibilities
The tenant usually obtains insurance in connection with the activities it is to perform and the property itself is usually insured by the owner. Most Civil Codes require the tenant to obtain insurance if a dangerous industry is to be carried out in the leased premises. The Civil Codes do not define this term, but it can include the highly risky activities set out in environmental legislation, such as nuclear power, explosives, and so on.
Grounds for termination
The landlord can terminate the lease if the tenant does not pay the rent as agreed in the lease. In addition, the landlord can terminate the lease if the tenant breaches other statutory obligations, including if the tenant:
Uses the leased premises for a use other than that authorised in the lease.
Damages the leased premises.
Makes alterations to the leased property without the landlord's consent.
Does not allow the landlord to make the necessary improvements.
The tenant can terminate the lease if the landlord does not grant use and enjoyment of the leased premises as agreed in the lease. Other statutory provisions allow the tenant to terminate the lease, including if the tenant's use of the leased premises is impossible due to eviction by the landlord.
Following the latest reforms of the Civil Code of the Federal District, if extraordinary unforeseen circumstances result in the obligations of a party being more onerous, that party can request the amendment of the contract to restore equity between the parties. If a court resolves in favour of the requesting party, the other party must either accept amendments or terminate the contract.
If the tenant is declared insolvent, the lease is not automatically terminated (Bankruptcy Law). However, a court-appointed conciliator in insolvency proceedings can rescind the lease. If he does, the tenant must pay the landlord the indemnity provided for in the lease. If the lease does not provide for an indemnity, the tenant must pay the landlord the equivalent of three months' rent (Bankruptcy Law).
The General Law on Human Settlements contains provisions concerning planning control. Similar rules and principles apply to the planning regime of the local states.
Each state and the Federal District have local statutes that regulate planning, covering use of land, zoning and construction. For the Federal District, these include the:
Law of Urban Development for the Federal District 2010 (Urban Development Law).
Regulations to the Urban Development Law for the Federal District 2004 (Urban Development Regulations).
Environmental Law for the Federal District 2000.
Construction Regulations for the Federal District 2004 (Construction Regulations).
Detailed planning rules, based on the Urban Development Law and the Urban Development Regulations, are contained in urban development programmes. For the Federal District these are:
The General Urban Development Programme. This sets out the planning strategies, policies, actions and rules to be followed in the Federal District. It is the basis of the other two programmes (see below), and of the general planning and urban development objectives for the Federal District. It must be interpreted according to applicable federal or local statutes, such as the:
National Development Plan;
National Urban Development Programme; and
General Urban Development Programme of the Federal District.
Political subdivisions' programmes (programas delegacionales). The territory of the Federal District is divided into 16 political subdivisions and the territory of each state is divided into municipalities or political subdivisions. These programmes provide the urban development, planning and territorial regulations for a political subdivision (delegación política) of the Federal District (or the municipal programmes, in the case of a state). Each programme applies the policies of the General Urban Development Programme of the Federal District (some states have their own municipal urban development programmes).
Partial programmes. These provide urban development and planning for specific areas that, due to their rapid growth and urban development, require special attention and regulation.
Planning permission consisting of a zoning certificate is required for every construction project. A zoning certificate is an official document that typically regulates, for an individual property, the:
Use of land.
Permitted construction levels (governing matters such as the intensity and density of construction).
Restrictions on construction.
There are different types of zoning certificates (Urban Development Regulations):
A zoning certificate for permitted uses of land for a particular property. These are determined by the zone where the property is situated. This certificate can be used for up to two years from the date it is issued.
A master zoning certificate of specific use of land and amenities. This is used for:
housing projects of up to 200 homes or with an area of up to 10,000 square metres; or
commercial, industrial or services premises with an area of up to 5,000 square metres, except if an urban impact study is required.
This certificate can be used for up to one year from the date it is issued and sets out:
whether a property can be supplied with services such as water and drainage;
the urban impact of construction;
the layout of the local roads; and
the permitted use of land.
A zoning certificate for the specific use of land. This allows or prohibits a specific use of land for a particular property, according to the urban development programmes. It can be used for up to two years from the date of issue.
A zoning certificate of evidenced use of land by means of vested rights. This document acknowledges the rights of the owner or occupier and their successors to have a specific use for a particular property, provided that this use of land was permitted before the current urban development programme had effect. This certificate is permanent.
The Registry of Urban Development Plans and Programmes (Urban Registry) issues the zoning certificates.
For every construction project, the interested party must file a preliminary report (which must include the zoning certificate) with the Ministry of Urban Development of the Federal District (Ministry). The Ministry determines whether an urban impact study is required.
Construction licences are required for the construction, expansion, modification, repair or demolition of a building or installation, or for performing construction, repair or maintenance work on underground facilities (Construction Regulations). A construction licence is not required in several specific cases (for example, urgent repair works to avoid accidents). Each political subdivision issues construction licences.
In the Federal District, for example, the Ministry of Urban Development, through the Urban Registry, grants the initial planning consents.
Third party rights
Third parties do not have the right to object to the issuance of zoning certificates.
Neighbourhood consultation is required when any of the urban development programmes (see Question 40) are created or amended at the request of any individual or company. Consultation is not required for amendments to partial programmes.
The Urban Registry must issue a zoning certificate within the following time limits, calculated from the date on which the application is filed (provided the application is correct and complete):
A zoning certificate for permitted uses of land: five days.
A master zoning certificate of specific use of land and feasibilities of the proposed planning application: 30 days.
A zoning certificate for the specific use of land: ten days.
A zoning certificate of evidenced use of land by means of vested rights: 30 days.
A construction licence must be issued within 24 hours from the business day following the day the application is filed, assuming the application is correct and complete. In specific cases (for example, when applications relate to the construction, repair or maintenance of underground facilities), the licence must be issued within 30 business days of the date of filing, provided the application is correct and complete.
In practice, zoning certificates usually take longer to be issued, depending on the type to be issued. In practice, construction licences are usually issued within two to three months.
If a licence is denied or an interested party does not agree with the content of a zoning certificate, an appeal (recurso de inconformidad) can be filed with the same authority that issued or denied the licence, and the appeal is decided by a higher authority. The appeal must, by law, be resolved within 15 business days of being filed, although in practice it can take longer.
*The authors would like to thank Henry McDonald and Carlos Ordoñez of CB Richard Ellis for their help in the preparation of Question 1.
Real estate organisations
Ministry of Foreign Affairs (Secretaría de Relaciones Exteriores)
Main activities. This body grants permits for the acquisition of real property by foreigners outside the restricted zone and the incorporation of property trusts, and receives notices of purchases of Mexican properties by foreign individuals and other legal entities.
Ministry of the Environment and Natural Resources (Secretaría de Medio Ambiente y Recursos Naturales)
Main activities. This body regulates all matters relating to the preservation of the environment, orders the registration of contaminated sites on the public registry of property and approves the transfer of contaminated land.
Ministry of Urban Development of the Federal District (Secretaría de Desarrollo Urbano y Vivienda)
Main activities. The Ministry regulates urban construction projects and the use of land within the Federal District.
Association of Real Estate Developers (Asociación de Desarrolladores Inmobiliarios)
Main activities. This is currently one of the strongest associations of real estate developers in the country. Its members contribute around 80% of the real estate development in Mexico City, and more than half of the real estate development nationwide.
Mexican Association of Professional Realtors (Asociación Mexicana de Profesionales Inmobiliarios)
Main activities. This is a Mexican association of real estate professionals, which also offers certification and training programmes.
Description. Official website of the Ministry of the Interior, which contains up-to-date laws and legislation.
Description. Official website of the Congress, which contains up-to-date laws and legislation.
Description. Official website of the Official Federal Gazette (Diario Oficial de la Federación), which contains up-to-date information of the reforms and modifications to laws and regulations, as well as the publications of new laws and regulations. Every state has its own Official Gazette in which new state laws and reforms to state laws are published.
Description. Unofficial website which provides translations of Mexican law and regulations. PDF document translations have to be purchased via this website. Translations are for guidance only and are potentially out-of-date.
Jorge Torres Benítez
Creel, García-Cuéllar, Aiza y Enríquez, S.C.
Qualified. Mexico, 1985
Areas of practice. Real estate; tourism and corporate law.
- Counsel to Impulsora Mexicana de Desarrollos Inmobiliarios, S.A. de C.V., a major group of Mexican real estate developers and its partners, in the negotiation of the exit of a current partner and the participation of a new partner (a Singapore investment company) in an existing joint venture vehicle that acquired land and developed infrastructure and major urbanisation projects in the State of Querétaro.
- Counsel to Westmont Hospitality Group in the consolidation of a 100% ownership of the Hyatt Regency Cancún hotel.
Yusef Atiyeh Villarreal
Creel, García-Cuéllar, Aiza y Enríquez, S.C.
Qualified. Mexico, 2010
Areas of practice. Real estate; corporate law.
Counsel to Bank of America NA, in connection with its negotiations for the renewal of the lease agreements related to their offices in Mexico City.
Counsel to Exclusive Resorts in connection with financing for acquisitions and the sale of luxury residences in Mexico.