CFTC Issues Relief from Recent Cross-border Swaps Advisory and Requests Public Comment | Practical Law

CFTC Issues Relief from Recent Cross-border Swaps Advisory and Requests Public Comment | Practical Law

On January 3, 2014, the CFTC extended no-action relief, until September 15, 2014, from its controversial Dodd-Frank cross-border staff advisory on the US swaps activities of non-US swap dealers and MSPs. The advisory was scheduled to become effective on January 14, 2014. The CFTC also requested public comment on the staff advisory, which was issued on November 14, 2013.

CFTC Issues Relief from Recent Cross-border Swaps Advisory and Requests Public Comment

by Practical Law Finance
Published on 08 Jan 2014USA (National/Federal)
On January 3, 2014, the CFTC extended no-action relief, until September 15, 2014, from its controversial Dodd-Frank cross-border staff advisory on the US swaps activities of non-US swap dealers and MSPs. The advisory was scheduled to become effective on January 14, 2014. The CFTC also requested public comment on the staff advisory, which was issued on November 14, 2013.
On January 3, 2014, the CFTC extended temporary no-action relief, until September 15, 2014, from its controversial Dodd-Frank cross-border swaps staff advisory on the US swaps activities of non-US swap dealers (SDs) and major swap participants (MSPs). The staff advisory requires non-US SDs and MSPs (whether or not affiliates of a US person) to comply with Dodd-Frank Title VII transaction-level requirements (including clearing and real-time data reporting), even when entering into a swap with a non-US person that is not a guaranteed affiliate or a conduit affiliate of a US person if the SD or MSP uses personnel or agents located in the US to arrange, negotiate or execute the swap (see Legal Update, CFTC Closes Cross-border Swaps Compliance Loophole). The advisory was scheduled to become effective on January 14, 2014 (see Legal Update, CFTC Sets January 14, 2014 Effective Date for Cross-border Swaps Advisory). In an unusual action, the CFTC also requested public comment on the advisory nearly two months after its November 14, 2013 release. The staff advisory is a focal point of the lawsuit filed last month by three banking industry groups in the US District Court for the District of Columbia (see Legal Update, CFTC Sued over Dodd-Frank Cross-border Swaps Rules).
The lawsuit alleges that by issuing a series of informal guidelines and staff advisories, the CFTC illegally bypassed more rigorous and formal rulemaking requirements and expanded the scope of its regulatory authority to include a wider array of derivatives trading activities of these non-US entities. The CFTC did not address why it requested public comment on the staff advisory almost two months after its release. However, some view the gesture as a conciliatory move to the market, in light of the lawsuit, that could signal a softer approach to come from incoming CFTC leadership following the departure of outgoing Chairman Gary Gensler (and a number of other high ranking CFTC officials) who often had a contentious relationship with banking groups.
CFTC No-action Letter 14-01 extends from January 14, 2014 to September 15, 2014 the previous relief granted to non-US SDs from all applicable Title VII Dodd-Frank swaps transaction-level requirements under the Commodity Exchange Act (CEA), including clearing and real-time data reporting. For a list of transaction-level requirements, see Practice Note, The Dodd-Frank Act: Cross-border Application of Swaps Rules: Transaction-level Requirements. Relief was provided to non-US SDs (whether or not they are affiliates of a US person) from requirements to comply with transaction-level requirements when entering into swaps with non-US persons that are not guaranteed affiliates or conduit affiliates of a US person using personnel or agents located in the US to arrange, negotiate or execute such swaps. The relief was granted in order to enable non-US SDs to organize their internal polices, procedures and personnel to be in compliance with these transaction-level requirements once the advisory becomes effective.
The CFTC also requested public comment regarding certain compliance issues, including but not limited to:
  • Whether the CFTC should adopt the staff advisory in whole or in part.
  • Views on whether Title VII transactional requirements should apply to swaps with non-US persons that are not guaranteed affiliates or conduit affiliates of a US person that use personnel or agents located in the US to arrange, negotiate or execute such swaps.
  • Whether swaps with non-US counterparties should be treated differently depending on the nature of the SD (for example: depending on whether the SD is a guaranteed affiliate or a conduit affiliate of a US person).
  • Whether or not and to what extent a non-US SD should be able to rely on substituted compliance for relevant transaction-level requirements (see Legal Update, CFTC Issues Dodd-Frank Substituted Compliance Determinations for Non-US Jurisdictions).
  • The meaning of the word "regularly" in the phrase "person regularly arranging, negotiating, or executing swaps for or on behalf of an SD" and what specific activities are considered core, front-office activities of that SD's swap dealing business.
  • The scope and degree of "arranging, negotiating, or executing" swaps.
Public comments are due by March 10, 2014 (60 days after publication of the request in the Federal Register).
For details on cross-border application of Dodd-Frank swaps rules including recent releases and final rules, see Practice Note, The Dodd-Frank Act: Cross-border Application of Swaps Rules. For information on SDs and MSPs, see Practice Notes, Is Your Client a Swap Dealer or Major Swap Participant? and The Dodd-Frank Act: Requirements for Swap Dealers and MSPs Checklist.