Digital Business in Indonesia: Overview | Practical Law

Digital Business in Indonesia: Overview | Practical Law

A Q&A guide to digital business in Indonesia.

Digital Business in Indonesia: Overview

Practical Law Country Q&A 5-621-1310 (Approx. 22 pages)

Digital Business in Indonesia: Overview

by Muhammad Iqsan Sirie, Daniar Supriyadi, Nazly Parlindungan Siregar and Nalphian Seotang, Assegaf Hamzah & Partners
Law stated as at 01 Jun 2023Indonesia
A Q&A guide to digital business in Indonesia.
The Q&A gives a high level overview of matters relating to: regulations and regulatory, legislative and industry bodies for doing business online; setting up an online business; running a business online, including electronic contracts and e-signatures; implications of running a business online, including data protection, privacy protection and cybersecurity; rules relating to linking, framing, caching, spidering and metatags; jurisdiction and governing law; domain names; advertising and marketing; tax; protecting an online business and users; insurance; and proposals for reform.

Regulatory Overview

1. What regulations apply for doing business online (for business-to-business and business-to-consumer)?
The Indonesian Government recently enacted an e-commerce regulation to regulate all aspects of online commerce (including e-contracts, online advertisements and parties to e-commerce transactions) (GR No. 80 of 2019 on Electronic Commerce (E-Commerce Regulation)).
Other laws and regulations may also apply, depending on the type of online business and the activities involved.
For example, specific regulations issued by the relevant authority will apply to the:
  • Processing of individuals' medical information: Minister of Health.
  • Facilitating crypto asset transactions: Commodity Futures Trading Regulatory Agency (Bappebti).
  • Processing online payments: Bank Indonesia (BI).
  • Providing a peer-to-peer lending platform: Financial Services Authority (OJK).
2. What legislative bodies are responsible for passing legislation in this area? What regulatory and industry bodies are responsible for passing regulations and codes in this area?
The Indonesian House of Representatives (Dewan Perwakilan Rakyat) is responsible for passing legislation in this area, as in any other area of law. However, the government can also propose legislative initiatives. Legislation passed by the House of Representatives often empowers the President and ministries or statutory bodies to make further and more detailed regulations in specific areas of the law. These regulations can be issued as any of the following:
  • Government regulation (GR).
  • Presidential regulation.
  • Ministerial regulation.
  • Non-ministerial regulation.
  • Ministerial decree.
  • Non-ministerial decree.

Setting up a Business Online

3. What steps must a company take to set up an existing/new business online?
When setting up an existing/new business online, a company must:
  • Select and establish the appropriate business model (such as incorporating a limited liability company, representative office or forming a partnership).
  • Obtain licences, permits or certificates necessary for the business (for example, business identification number, electronic system provider registration certificate, e-commerce trade business licence, tax registration certificate, and any operational licence as required by the relevant laws/regulations).
  • Build, design and develop the website or mobile app for the business (whether by itself or through a third-party developer).
  • Register the domain name with the relevant registrar (for example, if the company plans to use the domain .id, it must register its domain with INDOREG, one of the authorised domain name registrars in Indonesia) (see also Question 26).
  • Engage third parties for data storage, online payment systems, logistics solutions and so on.
4. What types of parties can an online business expect to contract with?
Depending on the nature of the business or its business model, an online business in its early stages may enter into contracts with:
  • Third-party website or mobile app developers to design, develop, and maintain the website or mobile app.
  • Hosting providers for the website or mobile app.
  • Content providers or copywriters for any content displayed on the website or mobile app.
  • Online payment system providers to facilitate online payments.
  • Website or mobile app merchants and end-users.
  • Telecommunications operators, if the online business intends to make available a facility to pay for the service by deducting the users' cell phone credits or if it wishes to lease a telecommunication line/network.
  • E-signature or digital signature providers, if the online business intends to use electronic identification and authentication facilities.
5. Is there any law or guidance that might affect the design of the website or app (for example, relating to access by disabled people or children)?
While there are no specific legal requirements about website or app design, there are several laws and regulations that must be taken into account when designing website or app. For example, when collecting and processing a child's personal data, the website or app operator must obtain consent from the child's parent or guardian (Minister of Communications and Information Technology (MOCIT) Regulation No. 20 of 2016 on Personal Data Protection (PDP Regulation)).
Further, when collecting and processing the personal data of any disabled person, the data controller must use the appropriate communication means in consent notices to obtain the consent of the disabled person and/or their guardian (PDP Law). The consent notice and the website or app's policies must therefore be designed to comply with this requirement. However, at the date of writing, there was no clarity on the procedure for obtaining consent from the disabled person.
In addition, if the website or app is a user-generated content platform. MOCIT Regulation No. 5 of 2019 requires operators to make available a complaint channel where users can report finding illegal content.
6. What are the procedures for developing and distributing an app?
A company must first consider the desired design, functionality and features of the app. Subsequently, if the company cannot develop the app internally, a third-party app developer must be appointed. An agreement should be in place for this engagement, which should address, among others, ownership of intellectual property rights, security, maintenance services and a user manual for the app.
The app can be distributed via the company's website or through third-party marketplaces such as Google Play, Apple Store and Microsoft Store.

Running a Business Online

Electronic Contracts

7. Is it possible to form a contract electronically? Are there any limitations?

Requirements

Indonesian law recognises electronic contracts. The criteria for a valid electronic contract are as follows:
  • There must be mutual consent of the parties.
  • Parties to the contract must be legally entitled to enter into the electronic contract.
  • There should be a specific subject matter.
  • The contract must be lawful.
(Article 46(2) of GR No. 71 of 2019 on Application of Electronic Systems and Transactions (GR 71/2019)).
An electronic contract must be in the Indonesian language if it involves an Indonesian party. Electronic contracts can also be drafted in a bilingual format. In this case, a standard language clause should be included, which, among others, specifies which text will prevail in the event of a discrepancy between the Indonesian text and the foreign language text.
Although Indonesian law does not specifically regulate click-wrap, browse-wrap and shrink-wrap contracts, consent in these types of contracts can be provided by:
  • An act of acceptance that displays consent (for example, the ticking/clicking on the "I Agree" box).
  • The act of accepting an object and/or using the object (for example, entering into and continuing to browse on the website).
(Article 49(3), GR 71/2019.)
This means that, as long as the formation of any click-wrap, browse-wrap, or shrink-wrap contracts complies with Article 46(2) and 49(3) of GR 71/2019, such a contract is valid and enforceable.
In the e-commerce context, additional conditions for a valid and enforceable electronic contract are as follows:
  • The formation of the electronic contract complies with the terms and conditions (T&Cs) for the electronic offering.
  • The content of the electronic contract corresponds with the information in the electronic offering.
  • The T&Cs for the offering from the seller are received and accepted by the buyer.
  • The parties to the contract have the legal capability to enter into the electronic contract.
  • The electronic contract deals with a specific subject matter.
  • The offered product or service is not in contravention of applicable laws and public order.
(Article 52, E-Commerce Regulation.)
In addition, an electronic contract for an e-commerce transaction must also contain certain information, that is the:
  • Identity of the parties.
  • Specification of the offered product or service.
  • Legality of the product or service.
  • Price of the product or service.
  • Conditions and term for payment.
  • Procedure to operate the product or deliver the service.
  • Procedure for refunding the product if there is a discrepancy between the promised and the received product.
  • Procedure for cancelling order.
  • Governing law and the dispute settlement forum.
  • Once signed, the seller must allow the buyer to download or otherwise keep the electronic contract.
  • Under consumer protection law, the electronic contract must not incorporate any standard clause that harms the buyer (such as transferring the seller's responsibilities or requiring evidence of the loss or lack of usability of the purchased product).

Limitations

In addition to the local language requirements, the following documents must be manually signed and cannot be signed electronically:
  • Any contracts and deeds for the sale of immovable property or the transfer of any interest in immovable property.
  • Corporate documents, such as deed of establishment, articles of association (and its amendments), deed of shareholders' resolutions, and share/asset transfer documents.
  • A mortgage agreement over land or immovable property.
  • Any contracts and documents that are being used as legal evidence and proof in court proceedings.
8. What laws govern contracting on the internet?
The primary laws and regulations governing contracting on the internet are:
  • Law No. 11 of 2008 on Electronic Information and Transactions (EIT Law), as amended by Law No. 19 of 2016.
  • GR 71/2019.
  • The E-commerce Regulation. This distinguishes e-commerce platforms that serve business-to-business (B2B), business-to-consumers (B2C) and consumers-to-consumers (C2C) transactions. Accordingly, there are several requirements under this regulation that only apply to B2C and C2C platforms, including on contracting terms.
  • Minister of Trade Regulation No. 50 of 2020 on Business Licensing, Advertising, Development, and Supervision of Business Players in Electronic Commerce (Regulation 50/2020).
9. Are there any data retention requirements in relation to personal data collected and processed through electronic contracting?
Generally, the PDP Regulation requires an electronic systems provider to retain personal data for at least five years from the date when the relevant data subject ceases to be a user of the service provided by that provider, unless stipulated otherwise by other specific laws and regulations such as the:
  • Minister of Health Regulation No. 24 of 2022 on Medical Records, which requires certain medical records to be kept for 25 years from the date of its creation.
  • E-Commerce Regulation, which requires financial and non-financial transaction data to be kept for ten years and five years, respectively.
10. Are there any trusted site accreditations available to confirm that the website has complied with minimum cybersecurity standards?
A site accreditation is issued in the form of an electronic certificate (sertifikat elektronik), which can either be a certified site accreditation or a non-certified site accreditation (MOCIT Regulation No. 11 of 2022 on Governance of Electronic Certification Application (E-certification Regulation)).
There are three categories of certified site accreditation:
  • A domain validation that only validates a site domain and the applicant's ownership of the domain without any further assessment of the legality of the applicant.
  • An organisation validation that validates a site domain and the legality of that organisation as the party applying for the accreditation.
  • An extended validation that validates a site domain, the legality of the applicant applying for the certificate and any additional relevant validations.
Only a local certification authority (penyelenggara sertifikasi elektronik) can issue a certified site accreditation. A site accreditation issued by a foreign certification authority will therefore be deemed a non-certified site accreditation.
A list of local certification authorities can be found at https://tte.kominfo.go.id/. If a local certification authority does not provide a certified site accreditation service, a service provider can use an industry-accepted site accreditation issued by a foreign certification authority (for example, DigiCert) if the foreign authority has complied with the E-certification Regulation that is, having a local representative in Indonesia within four years from the enactment date of this regulation (that is, 22 September 2022).
In addition, a site accreditation issued by a foreign certification authority has less evidentiary value before an Indonesian court than an accreditation from a licensed local certification authority.
11. What remedies are available for breach of an electronic contract?
The general remedies available for a breach of contract apply. Typically, these are determined by:
  • The nature of the contract.
  • Any remedies specified in the contract.
  • The nature of the breach.
Remedies can include termination of the contract or monetary compensation/damages (but not punitive damages) and/or specific performance.
In addition, where there is a breach of a regulatory requirement, such as a breach of the obligation to allow buyers to refund, return, or exchange the purchased product, other remedies may apply.

E-Signatures

12. Does the law recognise e-signatures or digital signatures?

Applicable Legislation and Use

The following laws apply to electronic signatures:
  • EIT Law.
  • GR 71/2019.
  • E-certification Regulation.

Definition of E-Signatures/Digital Signatures

Under the EIT Law, an electronic signature is defined as electronic information (which includes, among others, electronic sound, text or symbol) attached to or associated to a different electronic information (such as a contract or other record), for which it serves as a verification and authentication tool.

Format of E-Signatures/Digital Signatures

There are two types of e-signatures:
  • E-signature with certification. This type of e-signature is similar to a digital signature, in that it involves the creation of a unique code (also called a digital certificate) that is designated for a specific legal subject. The digital certificate, which is issued by a certification authority, is created based on the legal subject's identification documents (including their ID card and handwritten signatures).
  • E-signature without certification. This type of e-signature is created without involving the service of a certification authority and may include a digitised version of a person's handwritten signature.
13. Are there any limitations on the use of e-signatures or digital signatures?

Implications of Running a Business Online

Data Protection

14. Are there any laws regulating the collection or use of personal data? To whom do the data protection laws apply?
The collection or use of personal data in Indonesia is regulated by Law No. 27 2022 on Personal Data Protection (PDP Law) issued on 17 October 2022, and its implementing regulations, including existing ministerial-level regulations enacted before the PDP Law if to the extent that they do not conflict with the PDP Law.
The existing regulations include the PDP Regulation, which applies to electronic system providers that use electronic systems (for example a computer program, a website, a mobile app, or an online platform) to collect, process, store, disseminate, transfer, allow access to, and/or erase personal data.
The PDP Law applies to:
  • Data controllers and processors established in Indonesia.
  • Data controllers and processors that are not established in Indonesia, but that process personal data of Indonesian data subjects. The coverage of the PDP Law also extends to the personal data processing of Indonesian nationals abroad.
The PDP Law also applies to personal data processing by private or public parties, although there are exemptions to its application, for example for the processing of personal data for personal or household activities. Unfortunately, the PDP Law is silent on the nature of these activities. This is expected to be elaborated in the PDP Law's implementing regulations.
There are also partial exemptions for some provisions in the PDP Law. For example, a data subject's rights can be derogated if the purpose of the personal data processing is for:
  • National security and defence purposes (for example a police investigation).
  • Law enforcement measures (such as the prosecution of criminal offences).
  • Public interest purposes (citizenship administration, social security, taxation and licensing).
  • Monitoring/supervision in the financial services, monetary, payment, or financial stabilisation sectors (those that fall under the supervision of BI, OJK, and Indonesia's Deposit Insurance Agency (Lembaga Penjamin Simpanan) (LPS).
  • Statistical and scientific research purposes (the PDP Law does not further elaborate this exemption category).
In addition, the PDP Law also grants a two-year transitional period from 17 October 2022 for data controllers, data processors, and other parties in a data processing activity to adjust their data processing practices to conform with the PDP Law's requirements. This means that while these requirements became effective from 17 October 2022, no sanction will apply for failure to comply during the transitional period.
However, some provisions of the PDP Law became effective immediately from 17 October 2022. These govern prohibited conduct related to data processing activities, which are considered criminal offences.
For example,
  • An organisation or a person that conducts illegal collection of personal data to make a profit for themselves or others, which may result in losses for the data subjects, is subject to a fine of up to IDR5 billion. In addition, the management or the individual responsible is subject to a prison term of up to five years.
  • An organisation or a person that illegally discloses personal data is subject to a fine of up to IDR4 billion and its management/individual is subject to a prison term of up to five years.
15. How does the law define personal data or personal information?
The PDP Law defines personal data as any data relating to an identified or identifiable natural person (data subject) that can be identified on its own or in combination with other information either directly or indirectly through an electronic or non-electronic system.
Specific personal data includes:
  • Data concerning health.
  • Biometric data.
  • Genetic data.
  • Criminal record.
  • A child's data.
  • Personal finance data.
  • Any other data deemed as sensitive personal data under the law.
General personal data includes:
  • An individual's full name.
  • Their gender.
  • Their nationality.
  • Their religion.
  • Their marital status.
  • A combination of personal data that identifies a person (for examples cell phone numbers and IP addresses).
16. Are there any limitations on collecting, storing or using personal data?
The PDP Law restricts the collection and use of personal data in that a data controller must be able to identify the appropriate “lawful basis” for each type of data processing that they perform (Article 20, PDP Law).
The PDP Law generally permits the collection and use of personal data to the extent necessary for the performance of a contract with data subjects, or for taking any action requested by the data subject with a view of entering into a contract.
The PDP Law does not specifically limit the storage of personal data in cloud. However, when personal data is stored, data controllers and processors have certain obligations under the PDP Law, such as ensuring appropriate security safeguards, including encryption of personal data.
Personal data can be transferred outside of Indonesia to another country if one of the following lawful bases for the processing exists:
  • The jurisdiction where the recipient is located has an equivalent or a higher data protection standard.
  • The data exporter has implemented appropriate and binding safeguards.
  • In the absence of the above, the data exporter has obtained the data subject's consent for the export of data.
In addition to the PDP Law, GR 71/2019 also applies to electronic system providers (such as online businesses) that process personal data using electronic systems (a website, a computer program, or an online platform). A provider can choose whether to process and/or host its electronic system and data, including personal data, onshore or offshore. However, offshore data processing must comply with the PDP Law.
Regardless of the location, a system provider must ensure that the authority can access its electronic system and data. This flexibility does not apply to businesses in several sectors, such as the banking and financial services sectors, as they are subject to sector-specific laws and regulations. For example, the OJK only allows commercial banks and insurance and reinsurance companies to host certain data overseas based on its approval.
17. Can government bodies access or compel disclosure of personal data in certain circumstances?
An electronic system provider that keeps personal data within their electronic system must provide access to the data for law enforcement purposes if the requesting law enforcement agency (such as the police or the anti-corruption agency) has a bona fide legal ground to request it (Article 23, PDP Regulation; Articles 26 and 29 of MOCIT Regulation No. 5 of 2020 on Electronic System Providers in the Private Sector, as amended by MOCIT Regulation No. 10 of 2021 (Private ESP Regulation)).
Under those regulations, before accessing or compelling disclosure of personal data, a law enforcement agency must give a written formal request setting out their statutory powers for its request, the purpose of the request and a specific description of the requested data.
If the law enforcement agency wishes to access the contents of the communication in an individual's electronic device, additional requirements will apply, including having to obtain a court order.
Under Article 21 of the Private ESP Regulation, a government body is entitled to both:
  • Request electronic data held by an electronic system provider.
  • Access the provider's electronic system.

Privacy Protection

18. Are there any laws regulating the use of cookies, other tracking technologies like digital fingerprinting, or online behavioural advertising?
Indonesian law does not explicitly regulate the use of cookies. However, if a cookie collects personal data, then the PDP Law applies, and the relevant requirements, such as the requirement to have a lawful basis for data processing, must be fulfilled.
See Question 16 for details of the lawful bases for personal data processing.

Cybersecurity

19. What measures must contracting companies or internet providers take to guarantee internet transactions' security?
In operating its electronic system (for example a website or mobile app), an electronic system provider must put in place certain security measures to prevent any failure or disturbance to its electronic system (including any transaction using, or taking place within, the electronic system). These measures can include implementing anti-virus or anti-spamming software, firewalls and intrusion detection.
In addition, an electronic system provider must register all its electronic systems with the MOCIT for accountability purposes.
20. Is the use of encryption required or prohibited in any circumstances?
21. Are electronic payments regulated?
Online businesses are free to incorporate a licensed payment system (obtained through a third party) that facilitates electronic payments on their websites. The PDP Law applies to the extent that the payment system collects or uses personal data.
However, an online business seeking to establish and operate its own payment system must obtain a licence from BI. The regulations that apply to payment systems providers are:
  • BI Regulation No. 23/6/PBI/2021 on Payment System Service Providers.
  • BI Governor Regulation No. 24/7/PADG/2022 on Application of Payment Systems by Payment System Service Providers and Payment System Infrastructure Providers.
22. Do any specific rules or guidance apply to websites aimed at (or that might be accessed by) children?
Specifically for online gaming, games must be rated and classified based on the standards that apply to the content of games as set under MOCIT Regulation No. 11 of 2016 on Classification of Interactive Electronic Games.
When consent is required in relation to a minor's personal data, only a parent or a guardian of the minor can give consent on the minor's behalf. A person under the age of 21 is generally regarded as a minor in contract-related matters (as regulated under the Indonesian Civil Code).
23. Are there any laws protecting companies within your jurisdiction that resell or market online digital content, services or software licences provided by a supplier outside the jurisdiction?
Law No. 8 of 1999 on Consumer Protection (Consumer Protection Law) generally excludes the liability of a business that resells or markets goods or services provided by a supplier outside the jurisdiction if, among others, the business does not modify the goods or services before reselling or marketing them.

Linking, Framing, Caching, Spidering, and Metatags

24. Are there any limitations on linking to a third-party website and other practices such as framing, caching, and spidering?
There are no limitations on the use of links to third-party websites and other practices such as framing, caching, spidering and using metatags. However, online businesses that carry out these practices must ensure that they are not facilitating or hosting illegal content. See Question 37 on illegal content.
25. Are there any limitations on the use of metatags or advertising keywords?

Domain Names

26. What limitations are there in relation to licensing of domain names?
The following regulations are relevant to the licensing of domain names:
  • EIT Law.
  • GR 71/2019.
  • Minister of Communication and Information Technology Regulation No. 23 of 2013 on Domain Name Management.
Under these regulations, a domain name must not include elements of pornography, gambling, terrorism, racism/discrimination, anything relating to personal data, violence, phishing, malware, hacking and others (such as fraud, trade mark or drugs).
Moreover, the use certain domain names are restricted, i.e. if such domain names contain the name of a geographic area (e.g. a state or a city) or the name of an official position or government institution.
There is no non-commercial/government domain name registrar in Indonesia. The Ministry of Communication and Information Technology, which initiated and promoted the high-level domain name .id and other related domain names, collaborates with the Indonesian Internet Domain Name Administrator (Pengelola Nama Domain Internet Indonesia) (PANDI), to manage these domains through the PANDI members. These include commercial domain name registrars. In practice, many registrars offer certain domain name free of charge to their customers.
27. Can use of a domain name confer rights in a word or phrase contained in it?
Domain names do not confer any additional rights unlike trade marks. Their registration process and the supervising body also differs from that of trade marks.
To register a trade mark, a party must file an application to the Directorate General of Intellectual Property Rights (DGIP) at the Ministry of Law and Human Rights of Indonesia. The application is subject to a formal examination, a publication phase and a substantive examination before the DGIP issues a trade mark certificate. The first-to-file principle applies and therefore the issuance of a certificate depends on the availability of the trade mark. Under Law No. 20 of 2016 on Trademarks and Geographic Indications as amended by Law No. 11 of 2020 on Job Creation (Trademark Law), even if a party has obtained a trade mark certificate, the trade mark is subject to:
  • Cancellation if it infringes another's rights or is applied for in bad faith)
  • Deletion (based on non-use).
Domain names are considered to simply be the address or the identity of a state administrator, person, business entity and/or the public, and are obtained on a first-applicant basis. This first applicant principle for domain names is different from the first-to-file principle in the intellectual property sector as the former does not involve any examination procedure (unlike for trade marks).
A domain name can be registered as a trade mark. In this case, the domain name will be considered as a mark, not a domain name, and the Trademark Law will apply.
If the domain name infringes a registered trade mark, this will be considered as passing-off in violation of the Trademark Law.
A party that wishes to object to the alleged infringement of a person's trade mark right must raise such an objection either during the publication phase or by filing a cancellation suit in the commercial court.
28. What restrictions apply to the selection of a business name, and what is the procedure for obtaining one?
A business name is usually either the company's name or its trade mark name.
The following restrictions apply when selecting a company name for a limited liability company:
  • The proposed name must not be legally being used by another company or be essentially identical to another company's name.
  • The proposed name must not:
    • conflict with public order and/or morality;
    • be similar to names of state, government, or international institutions, except as permitted;
    • consist of figures or a series of figures, characters or a series of characters that do not form words.
    (GR No. 43 of 2011 on the Procedure for Applying and Using Limited Liability Company Name.)
A party must apply for a company name before incorporating the company. This application must be submitted via the Ministry of Law and Human Rights' website.
In selecting a trade mark name, the following restrictions must be observed:
  • The trade mark name:
    • does not conflict with the law, religious values, morality, decency, or public order;
    • is not commonly used in the public domain; and
    • does not constitute a mere description of the goods or services.
  • The trade mark name is not principally the same as an existing registered trade mark or a mark that is already in popular use for goods and/or services of the same kind belonging to other parties.
  • The trade mark name is not principally the same as a geographical location.
  • The trade mark name does not closely resemble the names of popular figures or photos or names of statutory bodies owned by other parties, except as permitted in writing by the rightful party.
  • The trade mark contains functional forms.
See Question 27 for the procedure to apply for a trade mark.

Jurisdiction and Governing Law

29. What rules do the courts apply to determine the jurisdiction and governing law for internet transactions (or disputes)?

Jurisdiction

The courts apply the rules set out in Article 18 of the EIT Law. The EIT Law requires any agreement giving effect to an internet transaction to specify the governing law and jurisdiction for disputes. In the absence of such a provision, the courts should apply the principles of international private law and determine the governing law based on the following factors:
  • Where the agreement will be performed.
  • Where the agreement was made.
  • The connection of the parties to the agreement to any particular countries.
  • The currency used in the agreement.
  • Where the counterparty is incorporated.

Governing Law

30. Are there any alternative dispute resolution/online dispute resolution (ADR/ODR) options available to online traders and their customers?

ADR/ODR Options

The forum for dispute resolution is typically included in a website's terms of use or T&Cs.
The E-Commerce Regulation contains a provision that recognises ODR if the disputing parties have agreed to use this method to resolve disputes. This regulation provides little explanation of ODR, but allows the disputing parties to determine the ODR's specifics, including whether to use professional mediators or an accredited ODR service provider. The Ministry of Trade is understood to be developing a national ODR system that is expected to come into operation in 2024. This ODR platform will be linked with ASEAN's ODR system.
Alternatively, online traders and customers can use the ADR services provided by general ADR centres such as the Indonesian National Arbitration Board (Badan Arbitrase Nasional Indonesia).

Remedies

ADR/ODR options in the form of consultation, negotiation, conciliation, mediation, or arbitration can result in the award of either or both:
  • Damages (compensation).
  • Specific performance.

Advertising/Marketing

31. What rules apply to advertising goods/services online or through social media and mobile apps?
The main legislation that governs advertising (including online advertising) is the Consumer Protection Law, which generally prohibits the misleading or deceitful advertising of goods or services. Advertisements are considered as misleading or deceitful if, for example, they present the goods or services as having certain features that they do not have, such as:
  • A discount or special price on the advertised goods or services.
  • The goods are in a good condition or are brand new.
  • The goods or services have obtained sponsorship or approval, or contain certain equipment, advantages, work characteristics, or accessories.
  • The company that has the sponsorship, approval, or affiliation is the manufacturer of the goods or services.
  • The goods do not have hidden defects.
  • The goods originate from a certain area.
The E-Commerce Regulation and its implementing regulation, Regulation 50/2020, prohibit online advertisements that violate the rights of consumers or are contrary to anti-trust principles. Under Regulation 50/2020, an e-commerce business can self-publish its advertisements or hire a third-party e-commerce service provider (such as an online marketplace operator) to do so.
As Regulation 50/2020 does not regulate electronic advertisements in detail, e-commerce businesses must still ensure that their advertisements comply with the general regulations on broadcasting, personal data, consumer protection, and competition.
Indonesian law does not specifically regulate online behavioural advertising. However, the Indonesian Advertisement Ethics provide that if cookies are used to collect users' data (which are then used for advertising purposes), the users must be informed of the data collection and processing. If the cookies relate to the collection of personal data, the business must have a lawful basis for its collection.
See Question 16 for details of the lawful bases for personal data processing.
32. Are any types of services or products specifically regulated when advertised or sold online (for example, financial services or medications)?
The types of services or products that are specifically regulated when advertised online include:
  • Tobacco products. The advertising of tobacco products is regulated under Government Regulation No. 109 of 2012. For advertisement on the internet, the tobacco products' websites must include an age verification notice for anyone accessing the website.
  • Financial products. OJK Regulation No. 6/POJK.07/2022 of 2022 and OJK Decree No. 12/SEOJK.07/2014 give guidance on what financial service providers are permitted to do when advertising financial products to consumers, whether offline or online. These regulations also require financial service providers to be responsible for any third parties that they appoint to advertise their products.
  • Medication. Indonesian Food and Drug Authority (BPOM) Regulation No. 2 of 2021 on Guidelines to Supervise Advertisement of Medication establishes the advertising requirements for medication, including the requirement to obtain BPOM's approval before advertising certain medication, such as over-the-counter medication.
33. Are there any rules or limitations relating to text messages or spam e-mails?
Generally, personal data protection rules apply to marketing communications (whether text messages or spam e-mails). However, under OJK Regulation No. 6/POJK.07/2022 of 2022 on Financial Services Consumers Protection, a financial service provider cannot send any marketing communication to consumers without their prior consent.
34. Does your jurisdiction impose any language requirements on websites that target your jurisdiction or whose target market includes your jurisdiction?
The Indonesian language must be used in any electronic contracts or other forms of contracts that are signed in relation to an internet transaction involving an Indonesian party (Article 47(1), GR 71/2019). Other than that, there is no language requirement for websites that target Indonesia or whose target market includes Indonesia.

Tax

35. Are sales concluded online subject to tax?
Online sales or e-commerce transactions are subject to tax.
Under Directorate General of Tax (DGT) Circular Letter No. SE-62/2013 (2013 Circular), e-commerce transactions are subject to value-added tax (VAT) and income tax. The 2013 Circular classifies four types of e-commerce transaction models:
  • Online marketplaces: activities related to the provision of space for online shop businesses in an online mall where goods and/or services are sold.
  • Classified ads: activities related to the provision of space and time for displaying contents related to goods or services. Advertisers target users by placing advertisements on a website provided by an organiser.
  • Daily deals: activities related to the provision of space for businesses on a website where goods and/or services are sold using vouchers as means for payment.
  • Online retail: activities of selling goods and/or services by an organiser to buyers on a website, where the organiser is also the seller.
Law No. 7 of 1983 on Income Tax as amended by Law No. 7 of 2021 on Harmonisation of Tax Regulations (Income Tax Law) defines income as "any increase in economic ability received or earned, originating from within or outside Indonesia, that is used for consumption or to increase the wealth of the taxpayer, in whatever name or form".
Any income obtained or received by a taxpayer, including from online sale transactions, is subject to income tax. Depending on the type of transaction, the applicable income taxes include:
  • Corporate income tax.
  • Individual income tax.
  • Withholding tax.
Online sales or e-commerce transactions within Indonesia may be subject to VAT.
The following points apply to offshore e-commerce transactions with Indonesian customers under (Government Regulation in lieu of Law No. 1 of 2020, enacted as Law No. 2 of 2020 (Law 2/2020)):
  • VAT is charged on the use of offshore intangible goods or services within Indonesia through an e-commerce system.
  • Foreign and domestic e-commerce participants, that is, foreign sellers, service providers or e-commerce marketplaces, and domestic e-commerce marketplaces, can be appointed by the DGT as VAT collectors if their business activities in Indonesia meet the e-commerce VAT thresholds.
    Under DGT Regulation No. PER-12/PJ/2020, the thresholds are as follows:
    • a transaction value with customers in Indonesia exceeding IDR600 million within one year or IDR50 million within a month; and/or
    • traffic or access volume in Indonesia exceeding 12,000 within one year or 1,000 within one month.
    Under Minister of Finance Regulation No. 60/PMK.03/2022, the appointed VAT collector on transactions with customers in Indonesia must issue VAT collection slips, which can be in the forms of commercial invoices, billing, order receipts or similar documents providing information on the VAT collection and payment.
    VAT collectors must:
    • remit the collected VAT to the Indonesian Government through an electronic tax payment channel by the end of the month following the transactions using Indonesian rupiah, USD or any other foreign currencies determined by the DGT;
    • submit a quarterly report on VAT collection and payment through a designated electronic tax filing system and if requested by the DGT, submit a detailed transaction report of the collected VAT for a calendar year.
  • Foreign e-commerce players with a “significant economic presence” in Indonesia can be deemed to have a permanent establishment (PE) in Indonesia. An entity satisfies the significant economic presence criterion if:
    • its group's consolidated gross turnover reaches a certain threshold;
    • its total sales in Indonesia reach a certain threshold; or
    • the number of its active users (purchasers of goods or recipients of service through an e-commerce transaction) in Indonesia reaches a certain threshold.
    Until now, this provision has not been implemented in practice. The Minister of Finance has not issued any regulation to implement the provision, such as for defining the threshold.
    While Indonesia has introduced an electronic transaction tax (ETT), no operative regulation has been issued, and it has not yet been imposed. If a foreign e-commerce player cannot be deemed to have a PE due to a tax treaty, it will be subject to the ETT. The ETT will be imposed on any direct sales or sales through a foreign e-commerce platform.
  • A foreign e-commerce player can appoint a representative in Indonesia to collect, settle and report its VAT, income tax and/or ETT. The government is expected to issue additional regulations to further stipulate issues such as tariffs, calculation procedures, the significant economic presence concept and appointment of a representative.
Law 2/2020 applies until the pandemic status in Indonesia is revoked and at the time of writing was still in force.
The Indonesian Constitutional Court decided in October 2021 that Law 2/2020 was issued specifically to tackle the pandemic and therefore, the law should not have any legal force once the President revokes the pandemic status. However, provisions related to the appointment of e-commerce participants as VAT collectors have been included in:
  • Law No. 7 of 2021 on the Harmonisation of Tax Regulations.
  • GR No. 44 of 2022 on the Implementation of Value Added Tax and Luxury Goods Sales Tax (GR 44/2022).
  • Minister of Finance Regulation No. 60 of 2022 on the Procedures for the Appointment of Collectors and for the Collection, Deposit and Reporting of Value-Added Tax for the Utilization of Intangible Taxable Goods and/or Taxable Services from Outside of the Customs Area within the Customs Area via Trade through Electronic Systems.
The above provisions will continue to apply even after Law 2/2020 is deemed to be no longer in force.
An e-commerce business that does not have a presence in Indonesia but provides services to Indonesian customers must establish an e-commerce representative office (kantor perwakilan perusahaan perdagangan asing bidang perdagangan melalui sistem elektronik) in Indonesia if it either/both:
  • Transacts with more than 1,000 consumers annually.
  • Delivers more than 1,000 packages to its consumers annually.
(Regulation 50/2020.)
The intention of Regulation 50/2020 is for the e-commerce representative office to function as an onshore extension of the offshore e-commerce business (that is, not a separate legal entity from the business). Therefore, the offshore e-commerce business is liable for obligations incurred by the representative office.
The representative office's activities are limited to acting on behalf of the offshore e-commerce business in:
  • Fulfilling consumer protection obligations.
  • Conducting development of local merchants.
Settling any disputes or complaints regarding customers or end-customers in Indonesia.
A separate analysis would be needed to assess whether the presence of the representative office would trigger a foreign entity to be deemed to have a PE in Indonesia.
36. Where and when must online companies register for value added tax (VAT) (or equivalent) and other taxes? Which country's VAT (or equivalent) rate applies?
A company is considered to be an Indonesian resident for tax purposes if it is incorporated or domiciled in Indonesia. A tax resident company must be registered with the DGT and comply with all Indonesian tax obligations in respect of, among others, maintaining bookkeeping and paying corporate income tax, employee income tax, withholding tax and VAT.
A foreign company carrying out business activities through a PE in Indonesia must generally assume the same tax obligations as a resident corporate taxpayer.
VAT is due on events involving the transfer of VAT-chargeable goods or the provision of VAT-chargeable services within the Indonesian customs area. The standard VAT rate is 11%. VAT is calculated by applying the VAT rate to the relevant tax base. In most cases, the tax base is the transaction value agreed between the parties concerned.
Under Law No. 8 of 1983 on Value Added Tax and Luxury Goods Sales Tax as amended by Law No. 7 of 2021 on Harmonisation of Tax Regulations (VAT Law), VAT is imposed on the following transactions (where the supplier/provider is VAT registered and the goods/services attract VAT):
  • Delivery of goods within the customs area.
  • Import of goods.
  • Delivery of services within the customs area.
  • Use of intangible goods or services originating from outside the customs area within the customs area.
  • Export of goods (either tangible or intangible).
  • Export of services.
A sole trader or business entity that delivers goods or services subject to VAT exceeding IDR4.8 billion per year must register with the tax office as a VAT-able entrepreneur (Pengusaha Kena Pajak). The entrepreneur must collect VAT on the chargeable revenue by issuing a VAT invoice (Faktur Pajak), pay the payable VAT and file the monthly VAT returns.
See Question 35 for VAT imposition and collection of offshore intangible goods or services within Indonesia through the e-commerce system.

Protecting an Online Business and Users

Liability for Content Online

37. What restrictions are there on what content can be published on a website (for example, laws regarding copyright infringement, defamatory content or harmful content)?
The E-Commerce Regulation prohibits the publication of any illegal content on websites. Illegal content is defined as any content that is prohibited or violates the law according to the applicable laws and regulations relating to, among others, copyright infringement, defamation or "harmful" content.
Further, under the Private ESP Regulation, an electronic system provider must ensure that its electronic system does not contain or facilitate the distribution of illegal content. Illegal content is defined as content that:
  • Violates the law, causes social unrest or disrupts the public order.
  • Informs or gives access to prohibited content.
Illegal content includes gambling, pornography (including child pornography) content, radicalism content, terrorism content and content that incites public unrest.
38. Who is liable for website content that breaches these restrictions (including, for example, illegal material or user-generated material that infringes copyright or other laws, such as the law of defamation)?
Under the E-Commerce Regulation, the electronic commerce provider is generally liable for any impact or legal consequences arising from the illegal content. However, under Article 11 of the Private ESP Regulation, an electronic system provider whose platform allows use- generated contents is exempted from the liability for any illegal content transmitted or distributed on its platform if the provider has fulfilled its obligations, such as:
  • Providing a reporting channel that the public can use to report illegal content.
  • Taking immediate action to investigate and respond to user complaints about illegal content.
39. What legal information must a website operator provide?
Any person that operates a business to sell goods or services through an electronic system (such as a website or mobile app) must disclose at least the following information:
  • Identity of the seller and the seller's role (a producer or distributor).
  • Details of the offered goods and/or services.
  • Price and payment terms.
  • Method of delivering the offered goods and/or services.
(Law No. 7 of 2014 on Trade as amended by Law No. 11 of 2020 on Job Creation)
Under Article 13 of the E-Commerce Regulation, an electronic commerce provider must provide the following information:
  • Identity of the legal subject, supported by legitimate data or a document.
  • Condition and warranty of the traded goods and/or services (for example related to the legality, quality, or price of the goods and/or services).
  • The electronic system used, according to its function and role in the transaction.
40. Who is liable for the content a website displays (including mistakes)?
Under the EIT Law, an electronic system provider is prima facie liable for everything that takes place on its electronic system (for example, its website or mobile app), unless it can prove that the occurrence resulted from the wrongdoing of a third party.
In addition, the E-Commerce Regulation recognises the "safe harbour rules as adopted under the US Digital Millennium Copyright Act and the EU E-Commerce Directive. The regulation gives a broad immunity to e-commerce service providers and intermediary service providers (for example search engine providers) from the legal consequences of illegal third-party content.
The E-Commerce Regulation discharges e-commerce service providers from any liability for illegal content found on their platforms if they have acted expeditiously to remove or disable access to such contents after knowing of its existence (either by way of a report from a third party or finding it out themselves).
Providers are required to provide users with terms of use or T&Cs of the platform (which should expressly state that users can only use the platform for lawful purposes), and to use certain technology and/or feature in the platform that will allow users to report illegal contents. This aims to ensure that an e-commerce service provider is alerted to illegal contents on its platform.
41. Can an internet service provider (ISP) shut down (or be compelled to shut down) a website, remove content, or disable linking due to the website's content, without permission?
An ISP can only block access to websites if ordered to do so by the relevant authority (the Ministry of Communications and Information Technology). An ISP that fails to block access to websites with illegal content can face sanctions, such as the revocation of its business licence.

Liability for Products/Services Supplied Online

42. Are there any specific liability rules applying to products or services supplied online?
All products and services that are supplied in Indonesia (whether online or not) must be safe and must meet the specified product standards and the information as disclosed on the label or advertisement under the Consumer Protection Law.
Under the E-Commerce Regulation the online provider or seller of goods must give consumers the right to exchange or cancel the purchased goods or services within at least within two business days after the date of receipt.
Further, Regulation 50/2020 governs the liability of electronic commerce providers for electronic advertisements for their goods or services.

Insurance

43. What types of insurance does an online business usually need?
Online business must have both:
  • Standard business insurance depending on the sector where it operates.
  • Insurance products that cover cyber liability.

Reform

44. Are there any proposals to reform digital business law in your jurisdiction?
Over the past three to five years, the Indonesian public has become more aware of personal data protection matters, primarily due to the rising numbers of data-related incidents. The government recently enacted the PDP Law (see Question 14 and Question 16) which establishes underlying principles for personal data protection, as opposed to detailed or practical rules. Implementing regulations/guidelines are expected to be issued to further regulate and clarify the provisions of the PDP Law.
In addition, the government is currently reforming the financial services sector regulatory framework, including recently passing a law on the development and strengthening of financial services sector which will have an impact on digital businesses in the financial services sector, including Fintech and cryptoassets. The OJK will be given additional authorities and powers, which include the authorities and powers to oversee and regulate crypto transactions which were previously tasked to the Bappebti. Once the law goes into effect, digital businesses engaging in crypto trading will be overseen by the OJK.

Contributor Profiles

Muhammad Iqsan Sirie, Partner

Assegaf Hamzah & Partners

T +62 212 555 7800
F +62 212 555 7899
E [email protected]
W www.ahp.co.id
Professional Qualifications. Advocate, Indonesia
Areas of Practice. Technology, media and telecommunications; M&A; general corporate law.

Daniar Supriyadi, Associate

Assegaf Hamzah & Partners

T +62 212 555 7800
F +62 212 555 7899
E [email protected]
W www.ahp.co.id
Professional Qualifications. Advocate, Indonesia
Areas of Practice. Technology, media and telecommunications; M&A; general corporate law.

Nazly Parlindungan Siregar, Partner

Assegaf Hamzah & Partners

T +62 21 2555 7800
F +62 21 2555 7899
E [email protected]
W www.ahp.co.id
Professional Qualifications. Chartered Accountant; Licensed Tax Consultant; Licensed Customs Expert; Licensed Tax Court Attorney, Indonesia
Areas of Practice. Tax.

Nalphian Seotang, Senior Associate

Assegaf Hamzah & Partners

T +62 212 555 7800
F +62 212 555 7899
E [email protected]
W www.ahp.co.id
Professional Qualifications. Licensed Tax Consultant, Indonesia
Areas of Practice. Tax.