Digital Business in Hong Kong: Overview | Practical Law

Digital Business in Hong Kong: Overview | Practical Law

A Q&A guide to digital business in Hong Kong.

Digital Business in Hong Kong: Overview

Practical Law Country Q&A 6-622-8758 (Approx. 22 pages)

Digital Business in Hong Kong: Overview

by Wilfred Ng, Michelle Chan and Olivia Cheng, Bird & Bird
Law stated as at 01 May 2023Hong Kong - PRC
A Q&A guide to digital business in Hong Kong.
The Q&A gives a high level overview of matters relating to: regulations and regulatory, legislative and industry bodies for doing business online; setting up an online business; running a business online, including electronic contracts and e-signatures; implications of running a business online, including data protection, privacy protection and cybersecurity; rules relating to linking, framing, caching, spidering and metatags; jurisdiction and governing law; domain names; advertising and marketing; tax; protecting an online business and users; insurance; and proposals for reform.

Regulatory Overview

1. What regulations apply for doing business online (for business-to-business and business-to-consumer)?
There are no specific laws governing the online conduct of business activities. However, there are several laws that regulate general commercial practices and are therefore relevant to online business activities. These laws include the:
  • Trade Descriptions Ordinance (Cap. 362) (TDO), that prohibits unfair practices conducted by businesses, including misleading actions or omissions, aggressive commercial practices and bait advertising.
  • Unconscionable Contracts Ordinance (Cap. 458) (UCO), that provides consumer protection in contracts for supply of services or sale of goods that are unconscionable. These contracts are set aside, altered or partially enforced.
  • Consumer Goods Safety Ordinance (Cap. 456) (CGSO), that provides that consumer goods must comply with approved and general safety standards or specifications.
  • Personal Data (Privacy) Ordinance (Cap. 486) (PDPO), that regulates the use and processing of personal data, including online processing or collection of personal data and direct marketing activities.
  • Unsolicited Electronic Messages Ordinance (Cap. 593) (UEMO), that regulates the sending of unsolicited electronic messages for promotional or marketing purposes, including by voice, text, image or video message, fax or email.
  • Electronic Transaction Ordinance (Cap. 553) (ETO), that recognises electronic records as having legal effect and regulates the use of electronic and digital signatures.
  • Payment Systems and Stored Value Facilities Ordinance (Cap. 584) (PSSVFO), that regulates stored value facilities and retail payment systems and is applicable to digital and electronic payment services.
  • Misrepresentation Ordinance (Cap. 284) (MO), that provides for statutory remedies relating to fraudulent, negligent, and innocent misrepresentation.
2. What legislative bodies are responsible for passing legislation in this area? What regulatory and industry bodies are responsible for passing regulations and codes in this area?
Ordinances are generally passed by the legislature of Hong Kong (Legislative Council).
Some ordinances also authorise specific government departments to publish subsidiary regulations to give effect to the provisions of the main ordinances. For example, the Secretary for Commerce and Economic Development can amend the scope of exempted persons or products under the TDO and can make regulations for safety standards for consumer goods under the CGSO.
For financial services institutions seeking to carry out regulated activities through the use of financial technology, the Securities and Futures Commission (SFC), the Hong Kong Monetary Authority (HKMA) and the Insurance Authority have each launched their respective regulatory "sandbox" initiative. This means that qualified firms can launch pilot schemes to a limited number of participating customers under close supervision by regulators in a confined regulatory environment before rolling out to a wider public. Where the initiative concerns a cross-sector Fintech product, the qualified firm need only apply to the regulatory sandbox it considers most relevant. This will enable it to gain concurrent access to multiple regulators through a single point of entry.

Setting up a Business Online

3. What steps must a company take to set up an existing/new business online?

Local Presence

Businesses should first consider whether to set up a local presence, for example a Hong Kong subsidiary company or registered non-Hong Kong company. However, there is no legal requirement that a company must first set up a presence in Hong Kong for its online business before the services and products to which the online business relates can be provided to people or businesses.
If the business wants a presence in Hong Kong and sets up a Hong Kong entity, it usually takes the form of a limited liability company that can be established by either:
  • Setting up a new company (which takes six to eight working days).
  • Acquiring a shelf company for immediate use (which takes three to four working days).
It is fairly straightforward to establish a subsidiary company in Hong Kong. The key legal requirements are:
  • There is no minimum capital subscription.
  • A company can be established with HKD1 issued share capital.
  • There is no residency requirement for the directors of a subsidiary.
  • It must have a company secretary and at least one director who is a natural person (that is, an individual).
  • If the company will only have one director:
    • the sole director must not also be the company secretary; and
    • the company secretary must not be a body corporate if the sole director of the body corporate and the company is the same person.
  • If the company secretary is a natural person, they must ordinarily reside in Hong Kong. If the company secretary is a body corporate, the address of its registered or principal office must be in Hong Kong.
  • Shareholders' meetings must take place annually (though written resolutions can be signed instead of holding physical meetings).
  • Company accounts must be prepared and audited annually. They are submitted to the tax authorities and are not filed in any public register.
  • For company name requirements see Question 26.

Specific Operating Permits

The company must determine if the proposed online business needs specific operating permits or approvals, for example a:
  • Telecom licence.
  • Payment related licence, for example, a stored-value facility licence or a money service operator licence.

Developing a New Website or Using an Existing Website

A new business can engage a website developer and internet service provider to develop and host the website (see Question 4). However, an existing business can consider localising its existing website to ensure compliance with Hong Kong law if the website is hosted in Hong Kong. The website must include:
  • A set of terms of use for the website itself.
  • A privacy policy section.
  • The relevant terms of sales or supply of service.
4. What types of parties can an online business expect to contract with?
An online business usually contracts with the following third parties:
  • Domain name registrar: a domain name registration agreement sets out the terms to use a domain name granted by the domain name registrant (see Question 24 to 26).
  • Website developer: a website development agreement should address the:
    • online business' requirements for the performance, functionality, security and visual design of the website;
    • maintenance obligations; and
    • ownership of intellectual property rights (IPRs), for example, in the design of the web pages and underlying software.
  • Internet service provider: a website hosting agreement should address the:
    • uploading, storage, security, maintenance and support of the website;
    • specification of the server; and
    • service levels or minimum availability requirements of the hosting services.
  • Content providers: if the business is not the owner of the content on its website, it should always obtain the appropriate licences from third parties. The business should also incorporate these licence obligations in the website's terms of use with end users. Generally, content licences should cover the:
    • scope and term of use for the content;
    • right to alter the content; and
    • updates of the content.
  • End users: the website should always include terms and conditions under which the end users can use and access the content of the website, and these should also include a privacy policy and (where applicable) terms of sale and service.
5. Is there any law or guidance that might affect the design of the website or app (for example, relating to access by disabled people or children)?

Website Accessibility

The Disability Discrimination Ordinance (Cap 487) has created a legal duty for organisations to ensure their services are available to everyone regardless of disability. This principle is applicable to information and services provided through websites.

Children's Access to Websites

The Privacy Commissioner (the enforcement body of the PDPO) has published a leaflet on "Collection and Use of Personal Data through the Internet – Points to Note for Data Users Targeting at Children" which sets out best practices for data users who interact with children (that is, a person under the age of 18) via the internet, including:
  • Avoiding (instead of just limiting) the collection of personal data.
  • Ensuring that children know, before taking part in any forum discussion:
    • who else may join the forums and have access to all the discussions;
    • whether the forums are monitored/moderated by the data users; and
    • whether discussions can take place among a specific group of users;
  • Deleting and editing of posts should be offered so that children have a chance to change their minds or alter the content after posting.
  • Offering a readily accessible and user-friendly means for account holders to remove the account and all associated data collected by the data users if an online platform requires children to create accounts before using its services.
  • Encouraging children to involve their parents or teachers when collecting personal data from them.
  • Ensuring that children are well informed of their rights and offering them an easy and online way to completely remove personal data they have supplied to the data users or disclosed on such platforms.
For specific rules or guidance applicable to websites aimed at (or that might be accessed by) children, see Question 22.
6. What are the procedures for developing and distributing an app?
Businesses generally enter into app development agreements with software companies (app developers). Agreements should include the necessary software and content licences required to develop or distribute the app. They should also include details on the ownership of IPRs in any newly created or modified content or software.
Generally, businesses distribute apps through app store providers (for example, Apple, Google and Microsoft, which are the largest app store providers and their agreements are publicly available on their websites). Businesses enter into end user licence agreements that provide the terms and conditions that end users must accept to download and use apps. Businesses also enter into agreements with providers of third-party payment services for distribution of apps and services provided by businesses to end users and customers.

Running a Business Online

Electronic Contracts

7. Is it possible to form a contract electronically? Are there any limitations?
Hong Kong law recognises most contracts that are formed electronically.
However, there are exceptions for certain types of contracts listed under Schedule 1 to the ETO. For example, deeds or documents relating to land charges under the Conveyancing and Property Ordinance (Cap. 219) must be executed with a handwritten signature and must not be stored in electronic form.
To form a valid electronic contract, the following elements are required:
  • Offer.
  • Acceptance.
  • Consideration.
  • Intention to create legal relations.
When contracting online, businesses should particularly consider offer and acceptance and the incorporation of terms.

Offer and Acceptance

For a business to have control over the terms of the contract, a website's terms and conditions usually state that:
  • By completing an online form or order the customer is making an offer.
  • When the business receives the order it will communicate its acceptance of the customer's offer (for example, by sending an email confirmation, displaying an acknowledgement on its website or by delivering the goods ordered).

Incorporation of Terms

The terms of the contract must be sufficiently brought to the attention of the customer before the contract is made. If not, the standard terms of the business will not be successfully incorporated into the contract. In practice, the most effective way is to design the website so that the customer must scroll down to the bottom of the entire set of terms and conditions on-screen and click an "I accept" button (or similar) before they can complete the order.

Consideration and Intention to Create Legal Relations

Generally, consideration is evident for most online contracts. It is either when a supply of goods or services is made in exchange for a customer's payment, or a customer accepts the terms of use in exchange for access to the website or software (if it is free access).
In addition, the intention to create legal relations is normally presumed for most online contracts due to the commercial nature of these transactions.

Click-Wrap, Browse-Wrap and Shrink-Wrap Contracts

To the extent that any click-wrap, browse-wrap, and shrink-wrap contracts have the four elements outlined above, these contracts are legally enforceable.

Excluded Contracts

The ETO does not apply to certain contracts, for example, assignments of interests in land. These contracts cannot be validly formed electronically and must be prepared and executed in the traditional paper-based manner.
8. What laws govern contracting on the internet?

Business-to-Business (B2B) Contracts

There are no specific statutory provisions regulating online contracting activities. Businesses should therefore generally comply with general contract law and all relevant statutory requirements that could apply to online contracting. The ordinances that are applicable include the:
  • ETO.
  • MO.
  • Sale of Goods Ordinance (Cap. 26) (SGO).
  • Supply of Services Implied Terms Ordinance (Cap. 457).
  • Control of Exemption Clauses Ordinance (Cap. 71) (CECO).

Consumer Contracts

Businesses supplying goods or services online must comply with the law applicable to B2B contracts (some of which cannot be excluded when dealing with consumers, for example certain implied warranties set out in the SGO). They must also comply with additional consumer-specific statutory control, in particular under the UCO and certain provisions in the CECO. If the court regards a contract or any part of the contract as unconscionable at the time the contract was made, the court can:
  • Refuse to enforce the contract.
  • Enforce the remainder of the contract without the unconscionable part.
  • Alter any unconscionable part.
(Section 5, UCO.)
When determining whether a contract or a part of it is unconscionable the court considers, among other things, the relative bargaining positions of the consumer and the business at the time when the contract was made and whether the terms and conditions were sufficiently drawn to the consumer's attention (section 6, UCO).
9. Are there any data retention requirements in relation to personal data collected and processed through electronic contracting?
A data user should not keep any personal data longer than is necessary for the fulfilment of the purpose for which the data is used (Data Protection Principle 2, Schedule 1, PDPO). There is no specific retention period prescribed in the PDPO itself.
10. Are there any trusted site accreditations available to confirm that the website has complied with minimum cybersecurity standards?
There are no official government accreditations for websites. However, some accreditations may be of interest to website providers, for example:
  • e-Cert, which is a digital certificate issued by the Hong Kong Post Office and other certification authorities recognised by the Government Chief Information Officer under the ETO. This is for secure online identification and supporting the validity of digital signatures (see Question 12).
  • ISO/IEC 27001, which is the international standard for information security management that is adopted by a number of IT service providers in Hong Kong.
11. What remedies are available for breach of an electronic contract?
Remedies available for breach of an electronic contract are the same as the remedies available for breach of any other type of valid contract, for example a claim for damages or seeking a court order for specific performance.

E-Signatures

12. Does the law recognise e-signatures or digital signatures?

Applicable Legislation and Use

E-signatures are recognised and the use of electronic signatures is governed by the ETO.

Definition of E-Signatures/Digital Signatures

An electronic signature consists of any letters, characters, numbers or other symbols in digital form attached to, or logically associated with an electronic record, and executed or adopted for the purpose of authenticating or approving the electronic record (section 2, ETO).
The ETO also recognises digital signatures as a form of electronic signature. In relation to an electronic record, a digital signature is an electronic signature of the signer generated by the transformation of the electronic record using an asymmetric cryptosystem and a hash function to the extent that a person having the initial untransformed electronic record and the signer's public key can determine the difference (section 2, ETO.)
This applies both in transformations generated by a private key corresponding to the signer's public key and where the initial electronic record was changed after the transformation was generated (section 2, ETO).

Application of Electronic Signatures and Digital Signatures

For transactions where all parties are non-governmental entities, signatories can agree to use electronic signatures or digital signatures.
For transactions that involve government entities, signatories must use digital signatures (supported by a recognised certificate issued by a certification authority).

Format of E-Signatures/Digital Signatures

An electronic signature is valid where:
  • The signatory attaches or associates the electronic signature with an electronic record for the purpose of identification and indicating the authentication or approval of the information in the electronic record.
  • Any method used by the signatory is reliable, and is appropriate, for the purpose for which the information contained in the document is communicated.
  • The person to whom the signature is given consents to the use of such method.
(Section 6, ETO.)
13. Are there any limitations on the use of e-signatures or digital signatures?
Electronic signatures are recognised for the purpose of most contracts. However, there are certain exceptions that require handwritten signatures including:
  • Testamentary documents.
  • Certain trust documents.
  • Documents concerning land and property transactions.
  • Powers of attorney.
(Schedule 1, ETO.)

Implications of Running a Business Online

Data Protection

14. Are there any laws regulating the collection or use of personal data? To whom do the data protection laws apply?
The collection or use of personal data is regulated by the PDPO. The PDPO applies to data users in the public and private sectors. A data user is a person who, either alone or jointly or in common with other persons, controls the collection, holding, processing or use of the data (section 2, PDPO).
15. How does the law define personal data or personal information?
The PDPO regulates "personal data", which means any data relating directly or indirectly to a living individual. It must be possible to directly or indirectly ascertain the individual's identity from the data. The data must also be in a form that makes access to or processing of the data practicable (section 2, PDPO).
For activities conducted by online businesses, "personal data" (for PDPO purposes) is likely to be either:
  • Information held or intended to be held in a computerised system.
  • Information held in non-automated records that are structured to enable access to information relating to living individuals.
16. Are there any limitations on collecting, storing or using personal data?
The PDPO prohibits the collection and use of personal data unless proper notification is given to the individual (Data Protection Principle 1, Schedule 1, PDPO). Notification must include:
  • The purpose of processing.
  • The classes of persons to whom data is transferred.
  • Whether it is obligatory or voluntary for the person to supply the data.
Personal data must be collected by lawful and fair means, for a purpose directly related to a function or activity of the data user, and the data collected should be necessary and not excessive (Data Protection Principle 1, Schedule 1, PDPO).
There are no specific limitations on the storage of personal data in the cloud under the PDPO. However, if businesses engage data processors to undertake data processing (which could cover cloud storage), they must ensure that the data processors comply with certain obligations (for example, not to keep personal data longer than necessary and to prevent unauthorised access or loss (Data Protection Principle 2, Schedule 1, PDPO)).
Online businesses relating to or concerning a sector or an industry that is subject to additional regulatory control on outsourcing (for example, insurance and banking), and that engage cloud service providers for storage purposes, trigger additional regulatory requirements including the requirement that the cloud storage arrangement is vetted by the relevant regulator, or the regulator must be notified of any material outsourcing arrangements. The regulator can be for example, the Hong Kong Monetary Authority if the online business is conducted by an authorised institution.
17. Can government bodies access or compel disclosure of personal data in certain circumstances?
Several public authorities and regulators have powers to access or compel disclosure of information (including personal data), for example the:
  • Privacy Commissioner can:
    • be provided with any information or document from persons that they think fit for the purposes of any investigation (section 43, PDPO); and
    • exercise its enforcement powers in relation to a revealing personal information (doxxing) or related offences, including requiring a person to provide relevant materials and answer relevant questions to assist an investigation (section 66D, PDPO) and applying for a court warrant to access electronic devices if there is reasonable suspicion that an offence has been, is being or about to be committed and relevant material or evidence is contained in the device (section 66G, PDPO).
  • Inland Revenue Department can request information on any employee from an employer, for example, place of residence or full amount of remuneration (section 52(2), Inland Revenue Ordinance (Cap. 112) (IRO)).
  • Customs and Excise Department, Hong Kong Police Force and the Independent Commission Against Corruption can apply for a prescribed authorisation from a panel of judges to intercept any communications in a telecommunications system for the purposes of preventing crime or protecting public security (Interception of Communications and Surveillance Ordinance (Cap. 589)).
  • Under the Law of the People's Republic of China on Safeguarding National Security in the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region, the Hong Kong Police Force or the Secretary for Justice have powers, among others, to apply for a court order to require a person or corporation that has the required information to answer questions or to furnish or produce relevant information or material to assist an investigation related to certain national security offences.

Privacy Protection

18. Are there any laws regulating the use of cookies, other tracking technologies like digital fingerprinting, or online behavioural advertising?
There are no specific regulations on the use of cookies. However, the use of cookies by website operators to collect, store or use personal data must comply with the relevant PDPO obligations (see Question 16 and Question 18). In particular, website operators must:
  • Provide the prescribed notification to end users and individuals when cookies are collected, including what kind of personal data is stored in the cookies and the purpose of its use.
  • State clearly whether the acceptance of the use of cookies by end users and individuals is mandatory to access the website.

Cybersecurity

19. What measures must contracting companies or internet providers take to guarantee internet transactions' security?
In the context of safeguarding the security of the personal data collected and used by the contracting companies and internet providers, data users must take all practicable steps to ensure that personal data is protected against unauthorised or accidental access, processing, erasure, loss or use (Data Protection Principle 4, Schedule 1, PDPO). Businesses must ensure that measures providing an appropriate level of security are applied to internet transactions that involve the transmission of personal data.
If traders accept card payments from customers, it is likely that they must ensure that their systems comply with generally accepted industry standards on data security. This is because a number of payment card scheme operators are subject to the Code of Practice for Payment Card Scheme Operators, a self-regulated compliance code monitored by the HKMA, that requires the operations of payment card scheme operators to comply with industry accepted security standards.
20. Is the use of encryption required or prohibited in any circumstances?
Encryption is a common (but not mandatory) security measure used to protect personal data to comply with Data Protection Principle 4 of the PDPO. In a number of guidance notes, including the guidance note on cloud computing, the Privacy Commissioner (the enforcement body of the PDPO) recommends the use of encryption for electronic data for security purposes. The Privacy Commissioner indicates that security measures must be proportionate to the degree of sensitivity and likely harm caused by the loss or unauthorised access of personal data.
The use of encryption is not unlawful. However, the Import and Export Ordinance (Cap. 60) and the Import and Export (Strategic Commodities) Regulations (Cap. 60G) regulate the import and export of certain types of encryption software.
21. Are electronic payments regulated?
Regulations govern the provision of payment services operated by:
  • Banks.
  • Deposit-taking companies.
  • Payment card scheme operators.
  • Retail payment systems operators, including the issuance of stored-value facilities that can be used as a means of making payments for goods or services.
These include the framework provided under:
  • BO.
  • Code of Banking Practice issued jointly by the Hong Kong Association of Banks and the Hong Kong Association of Restricted Licence Banks and Deposit-Taking Companies, and endorsed by the HKMA (a non-statutory voluntary code).
  • Code of Practice for Payment Card Scheme Operators (see Question 18).
  • PSSVFO.
Designated retail payment systems (RPS) must comply with system operation obligations, including ensuring the safety and efficiency of these operations and maintaining books and records of the relevant transactions (PSSVFO). While a range of payment systems may be potentially caught under the definition of RPS (including payment card, electronic funds transfer, transaction acquiring and payment gateway), the HKMA can designate a system an RPS only if the authority is of the opinion that:
  • The system's proper functioning is material to the monetary or financial stability of Hong Kong, or to the functioning of Hong Kong as an international financial centre (or is likely to become so).
  • The system should be so designated having regard to matters of significant public interest.
RPS include Visa, Mastercard, UnionPay International, American Express, Joint Electronic Teller Services Limited, and EPS Company (Hong Kong) Limited.
As records of electronic payments are produced and stored in electronic form, the electronic records are subject to the ETO.
In addition, if personal data is used for verification purposes or involved in the course of electronic payment, the website or the electronic payment operator must comply with the relevant security requirements under the PDPO.
The HKMA's Faster Payment System enables round-the-clock interbank fund transfers, and connects banks and stored-value-facility operators on the same platform, allowing members of public to transfer and receive funds by registering their mobile phone number or email address as an account proxy. The Common QR Code Standard for Retail Payments enables payment QR codes from different payment service providers to be converted into a single, combined payment QR code.
22. Do any specific rules or guidance apply to websites aimed at (or that might be accessed by) children?
There are no specific or express rules regulating websites that are aimed at children. However, there are certain sector-specific legislations that contain express provisions relating to under 18 year olds). For example, it is an offence to offer an indecent article to a minor, or to target a minor in any advertisements or promotional material relating to horse race or football betting or lotteries (Control of Obscene and Indecent Articles Ordinance (Cap. 390) (COIAO), Betting Duty Ordinance (Cap. 108)).
Additionally, there are certain limitations on the enforceability of contracts entered into with minors. General contract law will be relevant in determining if the contract is enforceable (see Question 6 to 8). A contract (for example, the website terms and conditions) entered into online with a minor will be enforceable only if the contract relates to "necessaries".
In relation to the personal data of a minor, and where consent is required in connection with the personal data (for example, the personal data will be used for a new purpose), and the minor is incapable of understanding the new purpose, the consent can only be given on the minor's behalf by a person with parental responsibility for that minor and if that person considers that it is in the minor's interest to permit such new use (section 2, PDPO and Data Protection Principle 3, Schedule 1, PDPO).
23. Are there any laws protecting companies within your jurisdiction that resell or market online digital content, services or software licences provided by a supplier outside the jurisdiction?
There are currently no laws that specifically protect companies in Hong Kong that resell or market online digital content, services or software licences provided by overseas suppliers.
The usual IPR issues must also be considered by companies reselling or marketing such content, services or licences, in particular, whether there is a legal right or permission to reproduce or communicate the content online.
Under the latest legislative changes pursuant to the Copyright (Amendment) Ordinance 2022, online service providers may be able to benefit from a statutory "safe harbour" defence for copyright infringements (see Question 41).

Linking, Framing, Caching, Spidering, and Metatags

24. Are there any limitations on linking to a third-party website and other practices such as framing, caching and spidering?
Linking, framing, caching, spidering and the use of metatags are subject to limitations under the general protection of IPRs.
If the link circumvents any subscription, pay or other barriers imposed by the original content owner, providing the link may not be permissible if the linking constitutes a breach of a third party's exclusive rights under applicable IPRs law. Whether an infringement occurs depends on the material used and the use made of it.
In addition, if information is extracted from a third party's website, it is also necessary to ensure that the use is not in breach of the terms and conditions of that website.
25. Are there any limitations on the use of metatags or advertising keywords?
The use of metatags or advertising keywords can potentially amount to trade mark infringement if it constitutes constitute use in the course of trade or business in relation to either:
  • Goods or services that are identical to those that are registered.
  • Goods or services that are similar to those that are registered and likely to cause public confusion.

Domain Names

26. What limitations are there in relation to licensing of domain names?
There are no specific regulations on the licensing of domain names. Therefore, general contract law principles regulate the relationship between the registrant of the domain name and the business licensing the domain name.
If a domain name also includes a trade mark owned by the registrant, the licensing of the domain name (under the domain name registration agreement) must include the right to use the trade mark. The licence must be in writing and signed by the licensor (trade mark owner) (section 33(3), Trade Marks Ordinance (Cap. 559)).
Any person can register a ".hk" domain; there is no residence requirement. However, only commercial entities registered in Hong Kong can register a ".com.hk" domain.
27. Can use of a domain name confer rights in a word or phrase contained in it?
Domain names themselves do not confer any additional legal rights. However, certain common law rights can be developed through usage. A domain name can also be capable of being protected as a registered trade mark.
A trade mark must be registered in the Trade Marks Registry of the Hong Kong Intellectual Property Department to be an enforceable trade mark. It is possible to register domain names as trade marks if they meet the requirements for registration (and consequently the registered trade mark can also be subject to invalidation or revocation).
The use of a domain name may give rise to unregistered trade mark rights for the owner and user of the domain name if, over time:
  • It acquires the attributes of a trade mark (that is, it distinguishes the goods or services of one undertaking from those of another undertaking).
  • A business can establish a reputation in the domain name.
If so, and a third party misrepresents a connection or affiliation with that domain name and as a result causes or is likely to cause damage to the business, that third party may be liable for committing an act of passing off.
28. What restrictions apply to the selection of a business name, and what is the procedure for obtaining one?
Any company name identical to that of an existing company, or appearing on the Companies Registry's index of company names, must not be used to incorporate a Hong Kong limited liability company. A company name can be in English, Chinese, or both. Businesses should search the register at the Companies Registry to ensure the proposed name of the company is not the same as, or similar to, a name that is already in use. The company name must also include the appropriate ending (for example, "Limited" or the equivalent Chinese characters). Company names (and changes to them) must be recorded at the Companies Registry as part of the company registration process.
The Companies Registry must approve company names that imply a connection with the Hong Kong Government or the Central People's Government or a body of either government, or contain certain words and expressions prescribed by the Financial Secretary (for example, chamber of commerce, savings, trust, or trustee).

Jurisdiction and Governing Law

29. What rules do the courts apply to determine the jurisdiction and governing law for internet transactions (or disputes)?
There are no differences between the rules that apply to internet transactions and those for other disputes.

Jurisdiction

The set of rules used to determine the jurisdiction is based on common law principles.
Generally, methods of establishing jurisdiction are either:
  • The defendant submitting to the jurisdiction of the Hong Kong court.
  • Correct service of process within or outside the jurisdiction (for example, a writ or originating summons).
Even if a defendant is effectively served, the defendant can seek to challenge the court's jurisdiction by demonstrating that there is a more appropriate forum.
Businesses can generally agree the jurisdiction between themselves with a jurisdiction clause in the contract. However, specific rules (or exceptions to the above general principles) may apply in non-contractual disputes, for example defamation or in cases concerning foreign IPRs.

Governing Law

General legal principles provide that the parties to an agreement are free to choose the law that governs that agreement, which is then the proper law of the contract.
Irrespective of the choice of law, certain specific mandatory legal rules may continue to apply, in particular statutory restrictions that apply to the parties' choice of law in a consumer contract (see, for example, section 17(2) of the CECO and section 7(2) of the UCO).
If the parties do not choose a governing law, the law with which the contract has the closest connection applies (factors to be considered can include the location of the subject matter or place of intended performance of the contract).
For non-contractual disputes relating to actions for torts, the subject matter must be actionable under both Hong Kong law and the law of the place where the act was committed. However, this is subject to a number of exceptions; for example, a particular issue of the subject matter may be governed by the law of the place that has the most significant relationship with the occurrence and the parties.
30. Are there any alternative dispute resolution/online dispute resolution (ADR/ODR) options available to online traders and their customers?

ADR/ODR Options

There are no specific dispute resolution services available to online traders and customers. However, there are some dispute resolution options available for certain aspects of electronic transactions and online business, for example:
  • The Hong Kong International Arbitration Centre (HKIAC) formulated the HKIAC Electronic Transaction Arbitration Rules for disputes arising from electronic transactions.
  • HKIAC offers online dispute resolution services for domain names, and administers dispute resolution proceedings for registrar transfers of domain names, internet keywords and wireless keywords.

Advertising/Marketing

31. What rules apply to advertising goods/services online or through social media and mobile apps?
There is no single comprehensive legislation or regulation governing advertising activities. Both online and offline advertising activities are generally regulated through the TDO (to the extent that any advertisement constitutes a trade description of any goods or services) and several specific laws that govern advertising of regulated products and services.
For example, the TDO prohibits online advertisements that contain any of the following:
  • A false or misleading trade description of the goods or services (for example, quantity, composition, availability, price or place of origin).
  • A misleading omission (for example, where material information, including the main characteristics of the product, price, identity of the trader, payment or delivery arrangements or the existence of any withdrawal or cancellation right, is hidden or omitted).
  • Bait advertising (for example, advertising at a specified price and failing to supply at this price for a reasonable period and in reasonable quantities).
In addition, the advertising of certain regulated products or services is subject to specific regulations, for example the:
  • Public Health and Municipal Services Ordinance (Cap. 132), under which advertisements must not falsely describe or mislead consumers about any food or drug, or its nature or quality.
  • Food and Drugs (Composition and Labelling) Regulations (Cap. 132W), that requires that any nutritional claims about pre-packaged food in an advertisement must comply with the prescribed requirements on nutrient content, comparison and function.
  • Undesirable Medical Advertisements Ordinance (Cap. 231), that prohibits advertisements relating to certain diseases and abortion.
  • Securities and Futures Ordinance (Cap. 571) (SFO) and codes of conduct or guidelines issued by the SFC, that apply to advertisements of financial services and products. For example, if an advertisement contains an invitation to enter into certain subscription or investment agreements or a collective investment scheme, it must be authorised by the SFC. A licensed or registered person must ensure that no false, disparaging or misleading information is contained in any of these advertisements (see Question 32).
On a self-regulated basis, the Association of Accredited Advertising Agencies of Hong Kong enforces a non-statutory code of practice against advertising agencies who are members of the association. Generally, the code of practice requires any advertisement to be legal, decent, honest and truthful.
32. Are any types of services or products specifically regulated when advertised or sold online (for example, financial services or medications)?
Generally, there is no distinction between the treatment for online or offline activities for the selling and advertising of products or services, as they are subject to the same regulatory approach (see Question 31).
Any business conducting online regulated financial services and issuing related advertisements must comply with the relevant regulatory requirements under the SFO or guidance issued by the SFC. For example, specific risk management and security controls are imposed on internet trading activities, and the provision of financial information may also trigger licensing or registration requirements.
33. Are there any rules or limitations relating to text messages or spam e-mails?
The UEMO is the main legislation that regulates text messages or spam emails. The UEMO sets out a number of statutory requirements that must be complied with if commercial electronic messages are sent out; for example, the information must be accurate and the recipient of the message must be able to unsubscribe.
The UEMO also prohibits, among other things, the sending of unsolicited marketing and promotional emails or text messages to subscribers on the do-not-call registers kept by the Communications Authority, unless the recipients gave their consent to receive the messages. However, several exemptions are available under the UEMO. In particular, businesses can, without consent from the recipients, send messages such as invoices or receipts to confirm or facilitate a transaction, or deliver goods or services for a transaction, that the recipients previously agreed to enter into.
The PDPO also regulates the sending of text messages or spam emails if the messages involve the use of personal data in direct marketing. Among other PDPO provisions on direct marketing activities, section 35G of the PDPO confers an absolute right to an individual to object to the use of their personal data for direct marketing purposes. The business or trader must stop using the personal data when they receive notification. The Privacy Commissioner, in the guidance note New Guideline on Direct Marketing issued in January 2013, states that the PDPO direct marketing provisions do not apply to the use of personal data for direct marketing activities targeted at a corporation (that is, if the personal data is collected from individuals in their official capacity and the product or service is clearly meant for exclusive corporate use).
In addition, organisations that collect personal data must inform affected individuals on the intended use of that data (Schedule 1, Data Protection Principles, Principle 1, PDPO). The PDPO also prohibits the use of collected personal data for purposes that are incompatible with the purposes for which the data was originally collected.
34. Does your jurisdiction impose any language requirements on websites that target your jurisdiction or whose target market includes your jurisdiction?
There are no specific language requirements for websites targeting Hong Kong. However, when the court decides whether a contract or any of its provisions are enforceable it will consider whether the consumer was able to understand the contract or relevant provisions (section 6, UCO). Businesses can avoid that risk by presenting the contract either in Chinese or English.

Tax

35. Are sales concluded online subject to tax?
Hong Kong adopts a territorial source principle of taxation. Profits tax is only charged on profits that arise in or are derived from Hong Kong. Therefore, whether sales concluded online are subject to taxation will depend on whether profits derived from the sales can be regarded as arising in or deriving from Hong Kong.
Profits tax is chargeable for each year of assessment for corporations (16.5%) and unincorporated businesses (15%), if:
  • The person concerned carries on a trade, profession or business in Hong Kong. This is a question of fact and degree that can only be determined on a case-by-case basis. Various factors including the nature of the contracts concluded in a jurisdiction, the place where the goods are stored and delivered (or in the case of services, the place where the services are provided) are taken into account when determining this.
  • The profits to be taxed come from a trade, profession or business conducted in Hong Kong. When determining whether a non-resident is carrying on a business or trade in Hong Kong, the concept of permanent establishment is assessed. Permanent establishment implies the presence of physical premises and personnel. If a business owns or leases the server on which its website is hosted, the business has a physical presence at the server's location. The business may or may not require any of its staff to be present at that location to operate the equipment.
  • The nature of the functions carried out by the business in the location is also relevant. For example, an internet service provider providing web hosting services in Hong Kong conducts a core function of its business in Hong Kong, and is therefore subject to profits tax. Conversely, a retailer selling books over the internet is not subject to profits tax if the business only operates a server in Hong Kong and the core business of selling books is carried outside Hong Kong.
  • The profits arise in or are derived from Hong Kong. This is a matter of fact and is determined by establishing the taxpayer's operations that produced the relevant profits and where those operations took place. The distinction between Hong Kong profits and offshore profits is made by reference to gross profits arising from individual transactions. Generally, the profits earned in Hong Kong by a taxpayer with a principal place of business Hong Kong are chargeable to profits tax.
(Section 14, IRO.)
36. Where and when must online companies register for value added tax (VAT) (or equivalent) and other taxes? Which country's VAT (or equivalent) rate applies?
There is no value added tax (VAT) on goods and services.

Protecting an Online Business and Users

Liability for Content Online

37. What restrictions are there on what content can be published on a website (for example, laws regarding copyright infringement, defamatory content, or harmful content)?
Website content is governed by a mix of statute and common law. Some key potential areas of liability for online traders are:
  • If a trader fails to comply with certain regulatory requirements imposed by the public enforcement authority, for example, to cease in any unfair trading act or false description of the goods or services on its website under the TDO, the authority can obtain an injunction to order the online trader not to continue, repeat or engage in the contravening conduct.
  • If the trader uses third party content online (including content on social media) without obtaining the relevant rights, it can be exposed to trade mark or copyright infringement claims. It is often assumed that content that is made available online (particularly on social media) can be freely used, but this is not the case and use without the correct permission potentially infringes IPRs.
  • Where content published on a website is defamatory, the victim may be able to obtain damages or an injunction (or both) requiring removal of the offending content from the website under common law principles.
  • There are several statutory offences that can potentially be committed through the publication of online content. For example:
    • the publication of obscene material can be an offence under the COIAO;
    • criminal liability may be incurred under the PDPO where a website operator publishes an individual's personal data online, without the consent of the data user (that is, the person from whom the individual's personal data was obtained by the website operator), with the intent to obtain gain or cause loss of money or other property, or cause any specified harm to the individual.
38. Who is liable for website content that breaches these restrictions (including, for example, illegal material or user-generated material that infringes copyright or other laws, such as the law of defamation)?
Both content providers and website operators may be liable depending on the nature of the wrongdoing. If for example the website is targeted at Hong Kong and the content provider's activity is illegal under Hong Kong law, the provider is generally liable for such content. However, the website operators can also be held liable (see Question 40).
39. What legal information must a website operator provide?
A company must state its registered name in legible characters and its liability status on its website (Section 4(c), Companies (Disclosure of Company Name and Liability Status) Regulation (Cap. 622B)).
If the website can collect personal data, a personal information collection statement must be included to satisfy the notification requirement (PDPO) (see Question 16).
Hong Kong law does not expressly prescribe the manner in which the terms and conditions of a website or the privacy notice must be presented on a website. In practice, the website terms and conditions, the privacy policy and other key information should be prominently displayed, particularly on consumer-facing websites, so that they do not fall foul of the UCO, or fail to meet the notification requirement under the PDPO.
40. Who is liable for the content a website displays (including mistakes)?
A website operator is liable for unlawful content displayed on its website unless it can rely on a defence. For example, it is a defence to a TDO offence if the contravening person can prove that both:
  • The commission of the offence was due to a mistake or reliance on information supplied to them or the act or default of another.
  • The person took all reasonable precautions and exercised all due diligence to avoid the commission of the offence.
(Section 26, TDO.)
For online businesses involving the publication of third-party content, both the author of the content and the website operator can be liable, depending on the wrongdoing alleged.
Accordingly, it is good practice for a trader to include disclaimers on the accuracy and availability of content on its website to limit the expectations of users and limit potential liability if the trader displayed content by mistake. However, this may not be sufficient if the trader is unable to establish it took due care.
Some traders include a term on their websites to provide for their right to cancel a contract based on mistaken information presented on the website. However, there is a risk that the term may be held unenforceable against a consumer under the UCO (see Question 7, Consumer Contracts).
41. Can an internet service provider (ISP) shut down (or be compelled to shut down) a website, remove content, or disable linking due to the website's content, without permission?
Most ISPs reserve their contractual rights to suspend their services to take down infringing websites, content or links.
Unlike the statutory defences for website operators (see Question 40) there is no statutory protection for ISPs for trade mark infringements. In the light of the Copyright (Amendment) Ordinance 2022 (commencement date to be confirmed), ISPs may potentially rely on a statutory defence for copyright infringements, provided that certain prescribed actions are taken such as taking reasonable steps to limit or stop the infringement as soon as it is notified.
There is no express statutory provision giving courts the right to grant an injunction against an ISP, where that ISP has actual knowledge of another person using their service to infringe copyright. The mere provision of physical facilities for enabling the making available of copies of works to the public does not of itself constitute an act of communicating infringing content to the public. In the absence of any statutory provision or established case law, an injunction may not be easy to obtain.
The Privacy Commissioner has powers to serve a notice to an ISP demanding that they cease revealing personal data if it has reasonable grounds to believe that the:
  • Data was disclosed without consent.
  • Discloser intended to cause harm to the data subject or its family.
  • Data subject is located in Hong Kong.
  • Cessation can be undertaken by a person located in Hong Kong.

Liability for Products/Services Supplied Online

42. Are there any specific liability rules applying to products or services supplied online?
The law applicable to the sale and supply of products and services offline also applies when they are sold or provided online. Therefore, an online auction site could be liable for auctioning counterfeit goods on the same basis as if the same counterfeit goods are auctioned offline.
Websites that provide services by aggregating online content or information from other websites using tools including web crawlers, scrapers, spiders, or other automated tools should also be aware that these operations can attract civil and criminal liability, including:
  • Breaching the terms of use of the websites from which the content is obtained.
  • Infringing the copyright of those websites.
  • Committing a criminal offence if they knowingly cause a computer to perform any function to obtain unauthorised access to any program or data held in a computer (section 27A, Telecommunications Ordinance (Cap. 106)).

Insurance

43. What types of insurance does an online business usually need?
Online businesses require the same sort of insurance as other businesses in the relevant industry sector within which they operate. In addition, online businesses should consider specific insurance policies covering the risks related to data privacy and network security from a data leakage or security breach.

Reform

44. Are there any proposals to reform digital business law in your jurisdiction?
The Hong Kong Government announced (in its Policy Address in both 2021 and 2022) that it is planning to introduce a cybersecurity law, focusing on operators of public utilities and other critical information infrastructure and their obligations to protect such infrastructure against cyber-attacks.
A public consultation exercise on this legislative proposal was expected to be undertaken in 2023. Against this backdrop, the Hong Kong Law Reform Commission released a consultation paper in July 2022 proposing the new cybercrime offences, which aim to rein in cybercrime with tougher penalties (up to the maximum of life imprisonment).
The proposed offences focus on crimes that can be committed only through the use of information and communications technology devices, where the devices are both the tool for committing the crime and the target of the crime.
In conjunction with the government's attempt in introducing a cybersecurity law, consolidated legislative efforts are expected to focus on formulating a general framework for protection of cybersecurity in Hong Kong.
The regulation of the transfer of personal data outside of Hong Kong under section 33 of the PDPO is not yet in effect and there is no concrete time frame for the government to put it forward for legislative approval. Pending section 33 becoming effective, business should follow the Guidance on Personal Data Protection in Cross-border Data Transfer and the Guidance on Recommended Model Contractual Clauses for Cross-border Transfer of Personal Data (including the Recommended Model Clauses annexed to the Guidance) issued by the Privacy Commissioner. This serves as a practical guide for data users to prepare for the implementation of section 33.

Contributor Profiles

Wilfred Ng

Bird & Bird

T +852 2248 6116
T +852 2248 6000
E [email protected]
W www.twobirds.com
Professional Qualifications. England and Wales, Solicitor; Hong Kong, Solicitor
Areas of Practice. Technology; media and telecommunications; intellectual property; commercial; data protection; corporate law.

Michelle Chan

Bird & Bird

T +44 20 7415 6000
T +852 2248 6000
E [email protected]
W www.twobirds.com
Professional Qualifications. England and Wales, Solicitor; Hong Kong, Solicitor
Areas of Practice. Technology; media and telecommunications; intellectual property; commercial; data protection; corporate law.

Olivia Cheng

Bird & Bird

T +44 20 7415 6000
T +852 2248 6000
E [email protected]
W www.twobirds.com
Professional Qualifications. Hong Kong, Solicitor
Areas of Practice. Technology; media and telecommunications; intellectual property; commercial; data protection; corporate law.