2009 Budget: pensions | Practical Law

2009 Budget: pensions | Practical Law

A summary of the main pensions-related points in the 2009 Budget.

2009 Budget: pensions

Practical Law UK Legal Update 8-385-8325 (Approx. 6 pages)

2009 Budget: pensions

by PLC Pensions
Published on 22 Apr 2009England, Scotland, Wales
A summary of the main pensions-related points in the 2009 Budget.

Speedread

On 22 April 2009, the Chancellor delivered his second Budget. There were three key pensions-related announcements:
  • From April 2011, higher-rate tax relief on pension contributions will be restricted for those earning more than £150,000. In the meantime, complex "anti-forestalling" measures will be enacted in the Finance Bill 2009, designed to restrict the relief available to those who change their normal pattern of pension saving in order to take advantage of higher-rate relief while it is still available. A special annual allowance charge will be levied on additional contributions to money purchase schemes above a specified level. Further accrual in defined benefit schemes will also be affected. Individuals will not be able to defeat the anti-forestalling measures by using salary sacrifice arrangements.
  • Provisions in the Finance Bill 2009 will ensure that compensation payable by the Financial Assistance Scheme and Financial Services Compensation Scheme will receive broadly the same tax treatment as payments by registered pension schemes.
  • For schemes that enter into stock-lending arrangements, measures announced in the 2008 Pre-Budget Report will be included in the Finance Bill 2009 disapplying charges to stamp duty and stamp duty reserve tax on the insolvency of one of the parties.

2009 Budget

On 22 April 2009, the Chancellor of the Exchequer delivered his 2009 Budget speech. This update summarises the key pensions-related aspects. For a detailed look at the wider measures announced in the Budget, see Legal update, 2009 Budget: key tax announcements.

Higher-rate relief restricted for pension contributions from April 2011

From April 2011, the availability of higher-rate relief on contributions to registered pension schemes will be restricted for those earning more than £150,000 a year. Tapering will operate so that for those earning above £180,000 a year, relief will be available only at the basic rate. A full consultation on these provisions will be announced in due course.
Anti-forestalling measures to be enacted in the Finance Bill 2009 have been published in draft. These are designed to prevent individuals likely to be affected by the change making pension contributions outside their regular pattern in the run-up to April 2011. The anti-forestalling measures will in turn be subject to anti-avoidance provisions.
The core of the anti-forestalling measures will be the introduction of a "special annual allowance", which will apply in the 2009/10 and 2010/11 tax years in addition to the standard annual allowance. The special annual allowance will apply to an individual who:
  • Has "relevant income" of more than £150,000 a year in the 2009/10 or 2010/11 tax year (or in either of the two tax years before each of those years). "Relevant income" means earnings within the charge to income tax, less allowable deductions and relief;
  • Changes his or her normal pattern of regular pension contributions, or the normal way in which pension benefits are accrued, after 22 April 2009 (in either of the tax years 2009/10 or 2010/11); and
  • Makes total pension contributions each year that exceed £20,000 (including any increases after 22 April 2009).
For 2009/10, the special annual allowance charge will be levied at 20% of the amount by which total contributions taken into account exceed the special annual allowance. In other words, the effect of the charge will be to restrict the available tax relief to the basic rate.
In assessing liability for the special annual allowance charge, an individual's "total pension input amounts" (as used for testing against the standard annual allowance) will be adjusted by deducting "protected pension input amounts". There will be two types of protected deduction: normal ongoing pension saving and contributions to new (or reactivated) schemes set up on or after 22 April 2009.
The draft legislation contains detailed provisions relating to what counts as normal ongoing pension saving. Broadly, for defined benefit schemes, further accrual will be protected provided there has been no material change to the way that benefits are calculated under the arrangement on or after 22 April 2009. Material changes could include changes in the calculation of pensionable salary or an increase in the accrual rate.
For money purchase schemes, contributions are protected provided that on or after 22 April 2009, the rate at which contributions are being paid under the arrangement does not increase otherwise than in accordance with an increase expressly agreed before 22 April 2009, and provided that the contributions were paid at least quarterly. Note that individuals whose regular savings exceed £20,000 for 2009/10 or 2010/11 will only be liable for the special annual allowance charge on the amount by which their contributions exceed their regular savings. So an individual with a pattern of contributions in excess of this sum can continue to make them without incurring the charge, and attract higher-rate relief until April 2011.
As the new measures have immediate effect, special provisions will allow an individual who has inadvertently become liable for the special annual allowance charge to take a "contributions refund lump sum" if scheme rules allow this. Contributions made to schemes between 6 April and 22 April 2009 will not be liable for the special annual allowance charge, but will reduce the amount of the allowance available for the 2009/10 year.
HMRC says that if an individual were to become liable for the special annual allowance charge in addition to the standard annual allowance charge, the special charge would be reduced to prevent double charging. A test against the special annual allowance will be made in the year in which a member retires, even though this does not trigger a test against the standard annual allowance.
Anti-avoidance measures contained in the draft legislation will provide that protection from the special allowance charge will be lost if an individual participates in a scheme or arrangement which has as its main purpose (or one of its main purposes) the avoidance of liability to the special annual allowance charge, the current annual allowance charge or the lifetime allowance charge by reducing either the total adjusted pension input amount or the protected pension input amount.
Likewise, HMRC seems keen that salary sacrifice should not be used to circumvent the new restriction: for individuals in these arrangements, an amount equal to the employer's pension contribution corresponding to the salary sacrifice will count as "relevant income". Indeed, in the case of any "scheme" which has as its main purpose (or one of its main purposes) to secure that an individual's income is less than £150,000, his or her income is deemed to be £150,000 in any event.
In addition to technical guidance and draft legislation, HMRC has also published guidance for the pensions industry and for individuals.

Tax treatment of FAS and FSCS compensation

Provisions in the Finance Bill 2009 will ensure that compensation payable by two public bodies will be treated on the same footing as payments by registered pension schemes:
  • FAS. Legislation will be amended to provide that lump-sum commutations payable by the Financial Assistance Scheme (FAS) will be tax free, as is the case with authorised lump-sum payments made by registered pension schemes. This move follows the government's December 2007 announcement that it was extending the FAS to provide compensation comparable to that provided by the Pension Protection Fund. The extension is being implemented in several phases: most recently, draft regulations were published for consultation in February 2009. Further regulations which will allow the FAS to pay lump-sum compensation are due to be published later in 2009 (see Legal update, DWP consults on latest FAS amendment regulations).
    In anticipation of these changes, the Finance Bill 2009 will contain a regulation-making power to adjust the tax treatment of FAS compensation. As a result, individuals will be entitled to take a tax-free lump sum on the same basis afforded to members of registered pension schemes.
  • FSCS. The Finance Bill 2009 will provide that compensation payable by the Financial Services Compensation Scheme (FSCS) in relation to tax-relieved pension saving will continue to benefit from the pension tax regime, as if the FSCS were not involved.
    The FSCS can either pay compensation itself to individuals or transfer an individual's rights to another insurer. In either case, the compensation payments currently do not count as payments by registered pension schemes. The amendments will broadly correct this, ensuring that individuals are not disadvantaged following the FSCS's involvement. This measure will be relevant for individuals with personal pensions and members of occupational schemes whose benefits have been bought out with an insurance company.

Stock lending: disapplication of charges on insolvency

As announced in the 2008 Pre-Budget Report, the Finance Bill 2009 will provide relief from stamp duty and SDRT charges that would arise if a stock-lending arrangement terminates and the stock is not returned to the originator under the terms of the arrangement owing to the insolvency of one of the parties.
A parallel relief will apply for the purposes of the tax on chargeable gains to avoid the charge which would otherwise arise under sections 263A and 263B of the Taxation of Chargeable Gains Act 1992. The changes will apply where the insolvency of the borrower or lender occurs on or after 1 September 2008.